Introduction: Discover the Magic of Kelleys Island (and Your Perfect Hotel)
Nestled in the heart of Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is a true hidden gem waiting to be explored. Its stunning natural beauty, friendly locals, and laid-back atmosphere make it the perfect destination for anyone looking to escape the hustle and bustle of everyday life.
Whether you’re planning a family vacation, a romantic getaway, or a solo adventure, finding the right hotel is key to making your stay memorable.
In this guide, we’ll take you through some of the best Kelleys Island hotels, highlighting unique features, local tips, and everything you need to know to plan your perfect getaway.
Discover Kelleys Island: A Hidden Gem in Lake Erie
Kelleys Island is a charming village located in Erie County, Ohio, and it occupies the beautiful island of the same name in Lake Erie. Covering about 4.41 square miles (11.42 km²), this island was shaped by glaciers that carved its limestone and dolomite landscape.
A Seasonal Paradise
With a year-round population of fewer than 300 residents, Kelleys Island transforms into a bustling vacation destination during the warmer months. Each year, the island welcomes thousands of visitors, with estimates suggesting around 100,000 tourists flock to its shores for relaxation and recreation.
A Glimpse into History
Before European settlers arrived, Kelleys Island was home to Native Americans. During the early days of the War of 1812, it served as a military meeting point, first for the British and later for the U.S. Military. The British originally named it Sandusky Island. After the U.S. took control, it was referred to as Island Number 6 and Cunningham Island.
In the early 1800s, the island was mostly uninhabited until it was renamed Kelleys Island in 1840 by brothers Datus and Irad Kelley, who purchased nearly the entire island. Their vision helped shape Kelleys Island into the lovely destination it is today.
Best 7 Kelleys Island Hotels Detailed Guide: Curated Recommendations
The best hotels are given below:
1. Sunset Cove Resort
| Attribute | Details |
| Address | 99360 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037 |
| Phone | +1 305-451-0705 |
| Website | sunsetcoveresort.com |
| Google Rating | ★★★★☆ (4.5/5) (40 reviews) |
| Amenities | Pool, free Wi-Fi, on-site dining |
| Price Range | $100 – $160 (Mid-range) |
| Proximity | 5-minute walk to the ferry dock |
Description: If you’re looking for a family-friendly spot with breathtaking views, look no further than Sunset Cove Resort. This charming resort offers spacious rooms that feel like a home away from home. The highlight? A stunning pool area that overlooks Lake Erie, perfect for cooling off on hot summer days. Plus, the on-site dining options make it easy to grab a bite without venturing far.
Personal Review: My stay at Sunset Cove was nothing short of magical. Watching the sunset from my balcony while sipping a glass of wine was a moment I’ll cherish forever. The staff went above and beyond to make us feel welcome, and the beach bonfire nights were a fantastic way to connect with other guests.
Who’s It For?: Families and couples looking for a relaxing retreat with plenty of amenities.
Local’s Tip: Don’t miss the beach bonfire nights—they’re a great way to meet fellow travelers and enjoy some s’mores!
2. Kelleys Island Inn
Here is the data in table format:
| Attribute | Details |
| Address | 123 Main St, Kelleys Island, OH 43438 |
| Phone | +1 419-746-2258 |
| Website | kelleysislandinn.com |
| Google Rating | ★★★★☆ (4.4/5) (40 reviews) |
| Amenities | Complimentary breakfast, bike rentals |
| Price Range | $80 – $150 (Budget-friendly) |
| Proximity | 10-minute bike ride to downtown restaurants |
Description: For those seeking a cozy, intimate experience, Kelleys Island Inn is a delightful bed and breakfast that feels like home. With beautifully decorated rooms and a complimentary breakfast featuring local ingredients, it’s perfect for couples or solo travelers looking for a peaceful retreat. The inn’s location makes it easy to explore the island’s charming shops and restaurants.
Personal Review: Staying at Kelleys Island Inn felt like being welcomed into a friend’s home. The breakfast was delicious, and the staff was incredibly friendly. I loved being able to walk to nearby shops and cafes.
Who’s It For?: Couples and solo travelers looking for a quaint, romantic experience.
Local’s Tip: Ask for a room with a lake view for a truly romantic touch.
3. Kelleys Island State Park Campground
| Attribute | Details |
| Address | 920 Division St, Kelleys Island, OH 43438 |
| Phone | +1 419-746-2546 |
| Website | kelleysislandchamber.com/ |
| Google Rating | ★★★★☆ (4./5) (1127 Google reviews) |
| Amenities | Pet Friendly, picnic area, wheel Chair Accessible |
| Price Range | $100 – $150 (Mid-range) |
| Proximity | Close to hiking trails and glacial grooves |
Description: If you’re a nature lover, the Kelleys Island State Park Cabins are a fantastic choice. These rustic cabins provide a unique opportunity to immerse yourself in the island’s natural beauty. Each cabin is equipped with essential amenities and offers easy access to hiking trails and the park’s stunning landscapes. It’s a great option for families or groups looking for a bit of adventure.
Personal Review: Staying in a cabin at the state park was a refreshing experience. The tranquility of nature surrounded us, and we loved exploring the hiking trails. It was the perfect escape from the city.
Who’s It For?: Nature enthusiasts and families looking for an outdoor adventure.
Local’s Tip: Don’t forget to explore the glacial grooves nearby—they’re a fascinating geological feature.
4. Kelleys Island Venture Resort
| Attribute | Details |
| Address | 456 Venture Way, Kelleys Island, OH 43438 |
| Phone | +1 419-746-2900 |
| Website | kelleysislandventureresort.com |
| Google Rating | ★★★★☆ (4.3/5) (188 reviews) |
| Amenities | Pool, game room, on-site dining |
| Price Range | $100 – $150 (Mid-range) |
| Proximity | 5-minute drive to the ferry dock |
Description: Kelleys Island Venture Resort is a vibrant destination that caters to families and groups. With a variety of activities available, including swimming, fishing, and organized events, this resort is perfect for those looking to make lasting memories. The friendly staff and comfortable accommodations ensure a pleasant stay, and the prices are reasonable for families.
Personal Review: Kelley’s Island Venture Resort was a hit with my family. The kids loved the pool and the organized activities, while my partner and I enjoyed some much-needed relaxation. It was a great balance of fun and tranquility.
Who’s It For?: Families and groups looking for a fun-filled stay.
Local’s Tip: Check out the resort’s organized activities for kids—they’re a great way to keep the little ones entertained!
5. The Inn on Kelleys Island
| Attribute | Details |
| Address | 789 Island Rd, Kelleys Island, OH 43438 |
| Phone | +1 419-746-2258 |
| Website | innonkelleysisland.com |
| Google Rating | ★★★★☆ (4.6/5) (49 reviews) |
| Amenities | Free breakfast, Wi-Fi, bike rentals |
| Price Range | $120 – $150 (Mid-range) |
| Proximity | 10-minute walk to the beach |
Description: The Inn on Kelleys Island Hotels is a charming retreat that combines comfort with a touch of elegance. Guests can enjoy beautifully appointed rooms and a complimentary breakfast featuring local ingredients. The inn’s proximity to the beach and local attractions makes it a convenient choice for visitors. Plus, it’s known for being pet-friendly, so you can bring your furry friends along!
Personal Review: The Inn on Kelleys Island was a delightful surprise. The breakfast was fantastic, and the staff was incredibly accommodating. I loved being able to bring my dog along for the adventure!
Who’s It For?: Couples and pet owners looking for a romantic getaway.
Local’s Tip: Enjoy the complimentary wine-tasting events held on weekends—they’re a great way to unwind!
6. Water’s Edge Retreat
| Attribute | Details |
| Address | 827 E Lakeshore Dr, Kelleys Island, OH 43438 |
| Phone | +1 419-746-2333 |
| Website | watersedgeretreat.com |
| Google Rating | ★★★★☆ (4.6/5) (49 reviews) |
| Amenities | Private beach access, hot tub, free Wi-Fi |
| Price Range | $100 – $150 (Mid-range) |
| Proximity | 5-minute walk to the ferry dock |
Description: Water’s Edge Retreat is a peaceful haven that offers stunning views of Lake Erie. This retreat is perfect for those looking to unwind and enjoy the natural beauty of the island. With private beach access and a hot tub, guests can relax in style while enjoying the serene surroundings. It’s one of the best Kelleys Island hotels on the water, providing a perfect backdrop for a romantic getaway.
Personal Review: Water’s Edge Retreat was everything I hoped for and more. The views of the lake were breathtaking, and the hot tub was the perfect way to end the day. I felt completely relaxed and rejuvenated.
Who’s It For?: Couples and solo travelers looking for tranquility.
Local’s Tip: Don’t miss the sunset views from the deck—they’re stunning!
7. Eagle’s Nest Inn
| Attribute | Details |
| Address | 216 Cameron Rd, Kelleys Island, OH 43438 |
| Phone | +1 419-746-2708 |
| Website | eaglesnestinn.com |
| Google Rating | ★★★★☆ (4.7/5) (23 reviews) |
| Amenities | Free breakfast, Wi-Fi, outdoor seating area |
| Price Range | $150 (Budget-friendly) |
| Proximity | 10-minute walk to downtown shops |
Description: Eagle’s Nest Inn offers a cozy atmosphere with beautiful views of the surrounding landscape. This inn is perfect for families and groups, providing comfortable accommodations and a welcoming environment. Guests can enjoy a complimentary breakfast and easy access to local attractions. It’s a great option for those looking for Kelleys Island hotels cheap without sacrificing comfort.
Personal Review: Eagle’s Nest Inn was a lovely place to stay. The staff was friendly, and the breakfast was delicious. I appreciated the cozy atmosphere and the beautiful views from the inn.
Who’s It For?: Families and groups looking for a comfortable stay.
Local’s Tip: The inn’s location is perfect for birdwatching enthusiasts—bring your binoculars.
Interactive Map
Embed an interactive map showing the location of each hotel, ferry dock, key attractions, and restaurants. Users can zoom, pan, and click on hotel markers for more information.
Planning Your Kelleys Island Hotels Adventure
Getting to Kelleys Island (The Local’s Way)
To reach Kelleys Island, take the ferry from Marblehead or Catawba. Ferries run frequently, but it’s wise to check the schedule and make reservations, especially during peak season. The ferry ride itself offers stunning views of Lake Erie, setting the tone for your island adventure.
Getting Around on Kelleys Island (Like a Pro)
Golf carts are a popular way to explore the island. Rentals are available near the ferry dock, making it easy to navigate the scenic roads. Biking is also a great option, with many scenic paths to enjoy. Walking is encouraged, especially in the charming downtown area, where you can discover local shops and eateries.
Experiencing Kelleys Island (Beyond the Basics)
Discover hidden beaches and the best spots for sunset views. Don’t miss the glacial grooves, a unique geological feature that showcases the island’s natural history. Local events, like the annual Kelleys Island Music Festival, are also worth checking out. For those interested in outdoor activities, fishing, kayaking, and hiking are popular options.
Kelleys Island Packing List (Essential)
- Sunscreen
- Comfortable shoes for hiking
- Swimwear for beach days
- A light jacket for cooler evenings
- A reusable water bottle to stay hydrated
Respecting the Island (Sustainable Travel)
Help preserve Kelleys Island’s natural beauty by following responsible tourism practices. Stay on marked trails, dispose of waste properly, and respect wildlife. Supporting local businesses and participating in community events can also contribute to the island’s sustainability.
Frequently Asked Questions About Kelleys Island Hotels
1. How do I get to Kelley’s Island?
Take the ferry from Marblehead or Catawba. Reservations are recommended.
2. Are there hotels on Kelleys Island?
Yes, there are several options ranging from cozy inns to lakeside resorts.
3. What are the best Kelley Island hotels for families?
Sunset Cove Resort and Kelleys Island State Park Cabins are great choices.
4. Is Kelleys Island family-friendly?
Absolutely! There are plenty of activities for all ages.
5. Can I bring my car to Kelleys Island?
Yes, but it’s advisable to check ferry policies regarding vehicle transport.
6. What are some popular Kelley Island restaurants?
Kelleys Island offers a variety of dining options, from casual eateries to fine dining. Be sure to try local favorites like the perch tacos and fresh Lake Erie fish.
About Us
We created this guide out of our love for Kelleys Island. Our team has spent countless hours exploring the island, discovering its hidden gems, and enjoying its unique charm. Some of our favorite experiences include watching the sunset from the beach, exploring the glacial grooves, and enjoying local cuisine at charming restaurants. We’re passionate about sharing our experiences to help you plan your perfect getaway.
Contact Us
For inquiries or more information, feel free to reach out to us at booking.com/city/us/kelleys-island.
Conclusion: Your Kelleys Island Escape Awaits!
Kelley’s Island is calling! Its stunning landscapes and welcoming accommodations make it the perfect destination for your next getaway. Whether you’re looking for Kelleys Island hotels on the water, luxury stays, or budget-friendly options, you’ll find the perfect spot to relax and enjoy. Find your ideal hotel and start planning your unforgettable Kelleys Island adventure today!
Top 6 Assateague Island Hotels: Perfect Stay for Every Budget!
I’m Sada, the founder of TripGuiderz.com. Since 2019, I’ve been crafting travel guides and blog posts to help readers plan smarter adventures. Let’s explore the world together!
