Welcome! Cowgirl SeaHorse is that rare NYC gem where Southern charm meets salty coastal vibes right near the South Street Seaport. From the moment you walk in, the colorful, quirky décor and warm atmosphere instantly make you feel like you have discovered your new favorite hideout.
The food? Pure comfort with a seaside twist. Whether you are diving into their famous shrimp & grits or just sipping on a frozen margarita during brunch, every bite feels like home (with a hint of honky-tonk flair).
In this article, we will explore the menu highlights, ambiance, and provide you with essential details to make the most of your visit. If you are looking for more information, be sure to check out the official Cowgirl SeaHorse website.
Quick Guide About Cowgirl SeaHorse
| Cowgirl SeaHorse | Detail |
| Rating | 4.3 out of (1,326 Google reviews) |
| Price Range | $20–30 |
| Cuisine Type | Tex-Mex Restaurant |
| Address | 259 Front St, New York, NY 10038, United States |
| Phone | +1 212-608-7873 |
| Hours | 11:30 am–4 am |
| Takeout Hours | 11 am–10 pm |
| Service Options | Serves happy-hour food · Serves great cocktails · Has kids’ menu |
| Menu | For the full menu and reservations, visit the official website here. |
| Description | Casual restaurant with offbeat nautical decor serving Southwestern faves, some with seafood twists. |
Savoring the Menu at Cowgirl SeaHorse
Brunch runs from 11 AM to 4 PM every Saturday and Sunday!
Weekdays from 11:30 AM to 4 PM
Appetizers
| Dish | Description | Price |
| Chicken & Waffle Fingers | Fried strips of chicken breast & waffles with Vermont maple syrup | $15 |
| Rattlesnake Bites | Jalapeños stuffed with grilled shrimp, wrapped in bacon with buttermilk ranch | $18 |
| Deviled Eggs | Six with a dash of paprika | $12 |
| Fried Dill Pickles | With buttermilk ranch (Buffalo chips +$2) | $12 |
| Sugar Reef Coconut Shrimp | Fried to golden perfection & served with sweet & spicy orange sauce | $18 |
| Corn Dog | Plump & juicy | $8 |
| Sweet Potato Fries | Sprinkled with pecans & served with creamy honey-dijon dipping sauce | $12 |
| Country-Fried Chicken Fingers | With carrots, celery & ranch dressing (Buffalo sauce +$2) | $15 |
| Chicken Wings | Traditional Buffalo style OR Huli Huli Hawaiian grilled pineapple wings | $16 (8 Pieces), $28 (16 Pieces) |
| Pulled Pork Sliders | With coleslaw, tangy BBQ sauce & fries | $16 |
| Mini Corn Dogs | Small corn dogs | $8 |
| Pretzel Bites | Soft pretzel nuggets with deli mustard | $7 |
| Giant Bavarian Soft Pretzel | With deli mustard, honey dijon & spicy cheese sauce | $17 |
| Burger Sliders | Black Angus from Pat LaFreida with fries | $16 |
| Buttermilk-Battered Onion Ring Tower | With buttermilk ranch & ketchup | $11 |
| Jalapeno Poppers | 4 jumbo poppers–cheese filled and fried to golden perfection | $13 |
| Tater Tot Basket | Tater tots with jack cheese, jalapeños, pico de gallo, sour cream & guacamole | $9 |
| Crab Balls | Five deep-fried with jalapeno tartar sauce | $16 |
| Baby Back Ribs | Half-rack rubbed with special blend of spices & BBQ sauce | $16 |
Hand-Cut Tortilla Chips
| Dish | Description | Price |
| Guacamole | Made fresh daily | $14 |
| Adobe Sauce | Rich & smoky chipotle sauce | $9 |
| Texas Caviar | Black-eyed pea salsa | $9 |
| Pico De Gallo | Fresh tomato, onion & peppers | $9 |
| Chile Con Queso | Classic tex-mex cheese dip | $16 |
| Patrick’s Pulled Pork Queso | Cheesy queso dip with house smoked pork | $21 |
Nachos
| Dish | Description | Price |
| Ground Beef | Black Angus from Pat LaFreida | $20 |
| Slow-Simmered Black Beans | $18 | |
| Chimayo Chicken | Garlic & herb marinated | $20 |
| House Smoked Pulled Pork | $19 | |
| Blackened Shrimp | $20 | |
| Hurricane | Nachos grande with ground beef, pulled pork, grilled shrimp & chimayo chicken | $28 |
| Crab & Shrimp | $25 |
Quesadillas
| Dish | Description | Price |
| House Smoked Pulled Pork | $19 | |
| Chimayo Chicken | Garlic & herb marinated | $17 |
| Slow-Simmered Black Beans | $16 | |
| Jack Cheese | $15 | |
| Blackened Shrimp | $20 | |
| Ground Beef | Black Angus from Pat LaFreida | $20 |
| Crab & Shrimp | $23 |
Salads
| Dish | Description | Price |
| Wedge Salad | Iceberg lettuce wedge with tomatoes, bacon bits & chunky blue cheese dressing | $13 |
| All Chopped Up | Romaine, avocado, scallions, tomatoes, Jack cheese, green apple, pecans, lemon poppy seed vinaigrette | $17 |
| Field Greens | Mixed greens, shaved carrots, tomatoes, radish, cucumbers & bell peppers | $12 |
| Burrito Boat | Black beans, rice, tomatoes, lettuce, pickled jalapeños, cheese & avocado | $17 |
| Taco Salad | Iceberg, tomatoes, avocados, pickled jalapeños, cheddar, tortilla strips, creamy lime vinaigrette | $15 |
| Seaside Salad | Mixed greens, parsley, dill, cucumbers, tomatoes & creamy lime dressing | $18 (Fish), $20 (Shrimp), $24 (Crab Cake) |
Enchiladas
| Dish | Description | Price |
| Ground Beef | $22 | |
| Shredded Chicken | $22 | |
| Jack Cheese | $20 |
Entrées
| Dish | Description | Price |
| Fish & Chips | Buttermilk-battered & fried with fries, coleslaw & jalapeño tartar | $22 |
| Shrimp & Grits | Shrimp sautéed with bacon, butter & hot sauce over creamy grits | $25 |
| Bayside Burrito | Black beans, rice, pico de gallo, guacamole, jalapeños & cheese | $18 |
| Blackened Fish Dinner | Served with rice & salad | $22 |
| Chicken Fried Chicken | Fried with mashed potatoes, cream gravy & veggie of the day | $21 |
| Southern Fried Shrimp Basket | Fried shrimp with fries, slaw & jalapeño tartar | $24 |
| Baby Back Ribs | Half-rack rubbed with spices & BBQ sauce | $30 |
Fajitas
| Dish | Description | Price |
| Mushroom Fajitas | $22 | |
| Chicken Fajitas | $23 | |
| Shrimp Fajitas | $25 |
Cowgirl SeaHorse Texas Tacos
| Dish | Description | Price |
| Slow-Simmered Black Beans | With jack, shredded lettuce & pico de gallo | $22 |
| Ground Beef | Black Angus from Pat LaFreida, jack, shredded lettuce & pico de gallo | $20 |
| House Smoked Pulled Pork | With coleslaw & BBQ sauce | $20 |
| Chimayo Chicken | Garlic & herb marinated, with jack, shredded lettuce & pico de gallo | $19 |
| Grilled Shrimp | With jack, shredded lettuce & pico de gallo | $22 |
| Southern Fried Fish | With jack, shredded lettuce & pico de gallo | $22 |
| Blackened Fish | With mango coulis, jalapeño tartar & fried capers | $22 |
Beach Baskets
| Dish | Description | Price |
| Egg Sandwich | Scrambled eggs with bacon & American cheese | $16 |
| B.L.a.T. Wrap | Bacon, romaine lettuce, avocado, tomatoes & chipotle mayo | $17 |
| Shoreside Fish Sandwich | Grilled, blackened or fried on a brioche bun with jalapeño tartar | $19 |
| Shrimp Shack Wrap | Chopped lettuce, tomato, onion, lime dressing & fried shrimp | $20 |
| Pulled Pork Sandwich | House smoked & dressed with North Carolina BBQ sauce | $19 |
| White Fish Reuben | With swiss cheese, sauerkraut & 1000 acre dressing on rye | $20 |
| Chicken Breast Sandwich | Grilled, fried or blackened with lettuce, tomato & onion | $18 |
| Cowgirl Half-Pound Burger | Certified Angus beef from Pat LaFreida | $18 |
| Scarf-A-Saurus Sandwich | Roasted jalapeños, bacon, jack cheese & sourdough | $18 |
| Buffalo Chicken Sandwich | Fried & dipped in buffalo sauce, topped with bleu cheese | $20 |
Sides
| Dish | Price |
| Mac ‘N’ Cheese | $9 |
| Hand-Cut Tortilla Chips | $6 |
| Soft Corn Tortillas (4 pieces) | $4 |
| Soft Whole Wheat Tortillas (4 pieces) | $4 |
| Creamy Coleslaw | $6 |
| French Fries | $7 |
| Cheese Grits | $6 |
| Rice | $6 |
| Slow-Simmered Black Beans | $6 |
| House Smoked Pulled Pork | $9 |
| Tater Tots | $9 |
| Rice & Beans | $8 |
| Small Sour Cream | $2 |
| Side Salad | $7 |
| Mashed Potatoes & Cream Gravy | $6 |
| Refried Beans | $6 |
| Veggie of the Day | $6 |
Dessert
| Dish | Price |
| Callebaut Chocolate Brownie | $8 |
| Peanut Butter-Pretzel Pie | $8 |
| Key Lime Pie | $8 |
| Coconut Custard Pie | $8 |
| Mont Blanc Tahitian Vanilla Ice Cream | $6 |
| Cowgirl’s Famous Ice Cream Baked Potato | $12 |
Cowgirl SeaHorse Drinks Menu
Signature Margaritas
| Signature Margaritas | Glass | Pint | Quart | Pitcher |
| Hand-Crafted Margarita On the Rocks | $15 | $22 | $40 | $70 |
| Cowgirl’s Famous Frozen Margarita | $14 | $26 | $56 | – |
| Mamacita Margarita (Skinny Margarita) | $16 | $24 | $44 | $77 |
| Shark-A-Rita (Frozen Margarita with Tequila Shark) | – | – | – | $19 |
| ¡Ay, caramba! (Hot & Spicy Margarita) | $16 | $22 | – | – |
| Hawaiian Bryan (Pineapple & Lime Margarita) | $15 | $16 | $22 | – |
| Dead Man’s Hand (Sweet & Hot Margarita) | $16 | $18 | $26 | – |
| Diving Dog Margarita (Coronarita) | $17 | – | – | – |
| One Piece at a Time (Old School Cadillac Margarita) | $15 | $17 | $24 | – |
| Super Smoker (Mezcal & Chipotle Margarita) | $16 | $18 | $26 | – |
| Passionista (Habanero & Passionfruit Margarita) | $18 | $26 | – | – |
| Mock-a-Rita (Non-Alcoholic Margarita) | $13 | – | – | – |
Super Fancy Margaritas
| Super Fancy Margaritas | Glass | Pint | Quart | Pitcher |
| Numero Ono (Reposado Margarita) | – | – | – | $18 |
| El Mejor (Herradura Reposado Margarita) | – | – | – | $20 |
| La Prima (Añejo Margarita with Grand Marnier) | – | – | – | $22 |
| El Jefe (Don Julio 1942 Margarita) | – | – | – | $47 |
Specialty Cocktails
| Specialty Cocktails | Size | Price |
| The Sun-Kissed Mermaid (Tequila Sunrise) | 16 oz | $15 |
| Seahorse Bloody Mary | 16 oz | $15 |
| The Flying Fish (Aperol Spritz with Gin) | – | $15 |
| Kill Devil Grog (Pirate’s Punch) | 16 oz | $15 |
| Cherry Lime Ricky | 16 oz | $15 |
| The Shipwreck (Seahorse Mojito) | 16 oz | $15 |
| Maiden Lane Michelada (Spicy Beer Cocktail) | 20 oz | $13 |
| Wrong Island Iced Tea | 16 oz | $15 |
| Paloma Kick (Spicy Paloma) | 16 oz | $15 |
| The Cyclone (Rum & Ginger Beer) | 16 oz | $15 |
| Manhattan Project (Bourbon & Cola) | 16 oz | $15 |
| Mule Day Queen (Moscow Mule) | 16 oz | $15 |
| Haymaker (Bourbon & Lemonade) | 16 oz | $15 |
| On Top of Old Smoky (Smoked Whiskey Old Fashioned) | – | $15 |
| Dirty Sharky (Dirty Shirley with Vodka) | 16 oz | $17 |
Non-Alcoholic
| Non-Alcoholic | Size | Price |
| Mock-a-Rita (Non-Alcoholic Margarita) | – | $13 |
| Sassy Señorita (Pineapple-Jalapeno Non-Alcoholic) | – | $13 |
| Heineken Zero | – | $8 |
| Guinness 0 | – | $8 |
| Sam Adams Just The Haze IPA | – | $8 |
The Ambiance and Experience
Cowgirl SeaHorse offers a cozy, laid-back ambiance perfect for every occasion. Whether you prefer the casual indoor seating or want to enjoy the outdoors on the patio, there’s a place for everyone.
The decor reflects a coastal cowgirl theme, adding a unique and charming touch to the atmosphere. It’s casual yet lively, making it ideal for everything from a casual lunch to a fun night out.
For those looking to enjoy some extra entertainment, they host live music events regularly, bringing even more vibrancy to the experience. You can also come by during Happy Hour for discounted drinks and a lively atmosphere.
5 Reasons Why Choose Cowgirl SeaHorse for Your Next Meal?
Cowgirl SeaHorse is a popular restaurant in New York, renowned for several reasons:
- Fresh Ingredients: They focus on using only the best, locally sourced ingredients in every dish, ensuring freshness and quality with every bite.
- Friendly Service: The staff is dedicated to providing excellent service, making every dining experience enjoyable and hassle-free.
- Relaxing Atmosphere: Whether you are in the mood for a quiet meal or a lively evening, Cowgirl SeaHorse offers an inviting atmosphere for all occasions.
- Diverse Menu: The menu caters to a variety of tastes, from seafood to burgers, ensuring that there’s something for everyone.
- Local Favorite: A beloved spot in Pacific Beach, Cowgirl SeaHorse has become a staple in the community, offering a consistent, delightful dining experience for locals and visitors alike.
Location, Hours, and Getting in Touch
Address:
Cowgirl SeaHorse is located at 259 Front St, New York, NY 10038, United States.
Location on Map:
Hours of Operation:
- Monday – Thursday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Friday – Saturday: 11:00 AM – 12:00 AM
- Sunday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
For reservations or inquiries, call [(212) 608-7873].
Convenient Online Ordering
Want to enjoy Cowgirl SeaHorse’s delicious dishes at home? It’s easy! Simply visit the Order Online page and place your order for takeout or delivery. Whether you are craving a burger, tacos, or seafood, we have got you covered.
Cowgirl SeaHorse Google Reviews Summary
Overall Google Reviews: 4.3/5 (⭐⭐⭐⭐☆) Based on 1,326 reviews
i) Ryan Greene: 4.9/5 (⭐⭐⭐⭐☆) (01-03-2025)
Dine-in
This place is fantastic! The decor is wonderfully eclectic, and the staff is super friendly. But the best part? The food! It was absolutely delicious. I highly recommend this neighborhood gem to anyone looking for a great dining experience.
Food: 5/5 | Service: 5/5 | Atmosphere: 5/5
ii) James Amster: 4.9/5 (⭐⭐⭐⭐☆) (07-24-2024)
Dinner | $20–30
Tucked away at the edge of the seaport, just under the Brooklyn Bridge, you will find this hidden gem. They offer an unpretentious mix of Tex-Mex with a seafood twist, along with some great burger options. I only had the nachos, but they were outstanding. The beef was top-notch, the guacamole was on point, and they make their own hot sauces my favorite was the green one. Unfortunately, they do not sell it for retail, or I’d buy a few bottles. I cannot wait to go back and try the burgers; I saw a few being served with huge, fluffy onion rings, and they looked amazing. This place definitely lived up to the hype it came highly recommended, and now I understand why!
Food: 5/5 | Service: 5/5 | Atmosphere: 5/5
For more reviews and ratings, visit Tripadvisor, Yelp, and Google reviews.
Conclusion
Cowgirl SeaHorse is the perfect destination for anyone seeking great food, friendly service, and a cozy atmosphere in Pacific Beach, San Diego. With a diverse menu of delicious dishes from fresh seafood to juicy burgers, you will always find something to satisfy your cravings.
Ready to enjoy the charm of Cowgirl SeaHorse? Visit the website today to view the full menu, place an order online, or make a reservation. They cannot wait to welcome you!
Also read these articles:
- Grandy’s Coney Island: A Legendary Dining Experience
- Jade Island Bordentown: Your Go-To Spot for Authentic Flavors
- Jade Island Warrington: Taste the Tradition, Love the Experience
- Bobbers Island Grill: The Ultimate Taste of Paradise on a Plate
- Fin Bistro Marco Island: The Epitome of Coastal Dining Excellence
- Lopez Island Creamery Menu: A Taste of Pure Delight
