Rothmanns Steakhouse is more than a restaurant. It is a historic fine dining experience located in East Norwich, Long Island. Known for its USDA Prime steaks, fresh seafood, and award-winning cocktails list, Rothmanns offers a timeless blend of flavor, atmosphere, and tradition.
Whether you are a local food enthusiast or planning a special night out, this guide will help you explore everything that makes Rothmann’s the best Affordable steakhouse on Long Island.
Discover the History of Rothmanns Steakhouse
Founded in 1907, Rothmanns Steakhouse has served guests for over a century. It is one of Long Island’s oldest steakhouses and has hosted U.S. presidents, celebrities, and countless locals seeking an exceptional meal.
From the days of President Theodore Roosevelt to today, Rothmanns remains a symbol of tradition and quality. This restaurant is a destination for anyone interested in historic dining on Long Island.
Why Did Rothmann’s Steakhouse in NYC Close? (And What Replaced It)
Rothmann’s Steakhouse, a longtime favorite in Manhattan at 3 E. 54th St., permanently closed in 2014. The space was taken over by celebrity chef Charlie Palmer, who opened his third Charlie Palmer Steak location there.
Many regulars—especially in the finance industry—missed Rothmann’s, but the new steakhouse brought a fresh dining experience to the same iconic spot.
Best Dry-Aged Prime Steaks in East Norwich
At Rothmanns, the star of the menu is the steak. The restaurant offers premium cuts of USDA Prime beef, dry-aged for over 38 days to enhance flavor and tenderness.
Popular cuts include:
- Bone-In Cowboy Ribeye
- Porterhouse for Two
- New York Strip (16 oz)
- Filet Mignon (8 oz and 12 oz)
Rothmann’s Steakhouse Prix Fixe Menu With Prices
Dinner Menu
Appetizers
| Item | Price | Description |
| Five Onion Soup Au Gratin | $15.9 | |
| Maine Lobster & Shrimp Bisque | $18.9 | |
| Sliced Tomato & Onion | $14.9 | Chas. Steak sauce |
| Baked Clams | $18.9 | Seasoned crumbs, olive oil, garlic |
| Kung Pao Calamari | $22.9 | Asian sweet chili, peanuts |
| Mozzarella Tower | $22.9 | Tomato, E.V.O., balsamic, basil |
| Applewood Smoked Slab Bacon | $22.9 | Maple soy glaze |
| Crispy Shrimp | $23.9 | Fried soba noodles, spicy peanut sauce |
| Grilled Octopus | $26.9 | Pickled red onions, olives, lychee, sunflower seeds |
| Maryland Crab Cakes | $29.9 | Jumbo lump crab, chipotle aioli |
| Lobster Mac & Cheese | $32.9 | Cavatappi pasta, imported cheeses, truffle crumbs |
| Seared Foie Gras | $33.9 | Balsamic glazed red onions, blueberry compote |
Raw Bar
| Item | Price | Description |
| L.I. Littleneck Clams | $2.9 | Per piece |
| Market Oysters | $3.5 | Per piece |
| Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail | $7.9 | Per piece |
| Maine Lobster Cocktail | $24.9 | ½ lobster |
| Maryland Lump Crab | $33.9 | ¼ pound |
| Seafood Plateau | $43.9 | Priced per person (clams, oysters, shrimp, lump crab, lobster) |
Salads
| Item | Price | Description |
| Classic Caesar | $17.9 | Imported shaved parmesan |
| BLT | $19.9 | Applewood smoked bacon, iceberg, beefsteak tomato, gorgonzola |
| Roasted Pear | $19.9 | Arugula, frisée, goat cheese, candied pecans, pomegranate-cranberry vinaigrette |
| Chas. Salad | $22.9 | Shrimp, bacon, onions, tomato, green beans, pimentos, red wine vinegar |
| Crab Salad | $23.9 | Lump crab, kani, cucumber, avocado, spicy mayo |
Sushi & Sashimi
| Item | Price |
| Kani | $5.5 |
| Salmon | $5.5 |
| Eel | $6.5 |
| Shrimp | $5.5 |
| Yellowtail | $6.5 |
| Tuna | $6.5 |
Appetizer Rolls
| Item | Price | Description |
| Pacific Roll | $22.9 | Spicy ahi tuna, cucumber, salmon, tuna, avocado |
| Tempura Roll | $23.9 | Shrimp tempura, avocado, mango, wasabi aioli |
| Salmon River Roll | $23.9 | Salmon, cucumber, mango, avocado |
| Buri Roll | $23.9 | Crunchy spicy yellowtail, spicy ahi tuna, jalapeño |
| Yellowtail Jalapeño Tataki | $24.9 | Sliced yellowtail, jalapeño, yuzu soy |
| Montauk Roll | $29.9 | Lobster, cucumber, spicy mayo, kani, crunch |
Signature Rolls
| Item | Price | Description |
| Chas. Roll | $34.9 | Spicy kani, avocado, cucumber, spicy tuna |
| Hampton Roll | $36.9 | Lobster, soft shell crab, cucumber, avocado, crunch, spicy mayo |
| Spicy Trio | $38.9 | Tuna, salmon, yellowtail, avocado & sriracha, spicy ahi tuna, side of kani |
| Gramercy Roll | $39.9 | Shrimp tempura, spicy kani, avocado, cucumber topped with spicy ahi tuna, crunch |
| Maguro Roll | $39.9 | 4 pc. tuna sashimi, 2 pc. tuna sushi, 2 pc. crispy rice spicy tuna, 1 pc. tuna avocado maki |
| Rothmann’s Roll | $39.9 | Maine lobster, seared filet mignon, avocado, truffle crunch, aioli |
Live Maine Lobster
| Item | Price | Description |
| Live Maine Lobster | MP | Choice of 2 or 3 lbs., broiled or steamed |
Chas. Specialties
| Item | Price | Description |
| Beggar’s Purse | $33.9 | Three cheese-filled pasta, sage madeira cream, dried cherries, arugula, frisée, pears, almonds |
| Chas. Prime Burger | $28.9 | 10oz. short rib brisket blend, bacon, cheddar, hand-cut truffle fries |
| Grilled Scottish Salmon | $39.9 | Grain mustard vinaigrette, grilled asparagus |
| Braised Free Range Chicken | $34.9 | Shallots, rosemary, pan jus, asparagus |
| Honey-Chili Glazed Swordfish | $46.9 | Grilled asparagus (spicy) |
| Sesame Crusted Ahi Tuna | $48.9 | Jícama, baby bok choy, cucumber slaw, orange soy |
| Alaskan Halibut | $48.9 | Yellow tomato purée, pico de gallo, micro greens, root vegetables |
| Colossal Shrimp & Lump Crab | $49.9 | Maple miso glazed, avocado crab salad, lemon dijon aioli |
Prime Steaks & Chops
| Item | Price | Description |
| Petite Filet Mignon (8oz) | $59.9 | |
| Prime Skirt Steak (16oz) | $59.9 | Asian marinade, crispy onion straws |
| Boneless Ribeye (18oz) | $63.9 | |
| Bone-In Veal Chop (16oz) | $63.9 | |
| Filet Mignon (12oz) | $69.9 | |
| Double Cut Lamb Chops (18oz) | $69.9 | |
| Classic Porterhouse (40oz) | $69.9 pp | For 2, 3, or 4 per person |
| New York Strip (16oz) | $69.9 |
Limited Reserve Steaks
| Item | Price | Description |
| Bone-In Rib Steak (18oz) | $79.9 | |
| Tomahawk Rib For 2 (43oz) | $79.9 pp | For 2 or 4, per person |
| Wagyu Bone-In Strip (16oz) | $175 | |
| Wagyu Porterhouse (40oz) | $175 pp | For 2 or 4, per person |
Enhancements
| Item | Price |
| Béarnaise | $5 |
| Hollandaise | $5.5 |
| Au Poivre Sauce | $5.5 |
| Rioja Demi | $5.5 |
| Gorgonzola | $6.5 |
| Truffle Butter | $6.5 |
| Foie Gras Butter | $6.5 |
| Colossal Shrimp (each) | $8.5 |
| South African Lobster Tail (5oz) | $39.5 |
Sides (Enough for Two – $14.9 each)
- Sweet Fries
- Asparagus
- Hash Browns
- Brussels Sprouts
- Sautéed Mushrooms
- French Fries
- Onion Straws
- Baked Potato
- Sautéed Onions
- Mashed Potatoes
- Creamed Spinach
- Truffle Fries
- Spinach
- Broccoli
- Sweet Mashed Potato with Candied Pecans
Note: Prices and items are subject to change.
Desserts menu
House Made Desserts
| Item | Price | Description |
| Crème Brûlée | $13.5 | Vanilla bean custard, caramelized sugar |
| Apple Galette | $13.5 | Caramelized apple in puff pastry, caramel drizzle |
| Pecan Pie | $13.5 | Pecans, brown sugar, graham cracker crust |
| Chocolate Molten | $13.5 | Flourless chocolate cake, crème anglaise, vanilla ice cream |
| Key Lime Pie | $13.5 | Custard, whipped meringue, graham cracker crust |
| Affogato | $13.5 | Vanilla ice cream “drowned” with espresso, whipped cream & chocolate shavings |
| N.Y. Style Cheesecake | $13.5 | Graham cracker crust, fresh fruit coulis |
| Fresh Berries With Cream | $13.5 | Assorted berries, housemade whipped cream |
| Salted Caramel Bomb | $13.5 | Salted caramel gelato, chocolate ganache shell, caramel |
| Ice Cream (single flavor) | $7.5 | Vanilla bean, chocolate, or coffee |
| Sorbet | $8.5 | Lemon or raspberry |
After Dinner Drinks (Topped with Fresh Whipped Cream)
| Drink | Price | Description |
| Caribbean | $12.5 | Malibu, Meyers, Amaretto |
| Fightin’ Irish | $12.5 | Jameson |
| Perfekte Koffie | $12.5 | Van Gogh Double Espresso Vodka |
| Decadent | $12.5 | Kahlúa, Bailey’s & Frangelico |
| Dark Monk | $12.5 | Frangelico, Hershey Syrup |
| Italian | $12.5 | Tia Maria or Strega |
Sunday Brunch
Details:
- Hours: 10:30 AM – 1:30 PM (Reservations Accepted)
- Pricing:
- Adults: $69.95 per person (includes 1 complimentary brunch cocktail)
- Children (under 8): $36.95 per child
- Holiday Pricing: $79.95 per person
- Note: Plus tax and service. Brunch seatings are limited to 2 hours.
Brunch Offerings
Brunch Cocktails & Champagne ($9 each)
- Mimosa
- Bloody Mary
- Screwdriver
- Bellini
- Champagne
Seafood Bar
- Chilled Maine Lobsters
- Shrimp Cocktail
- Oysters
- Clams
Sushi Bar
- Assorted Sushi, Rolls & Sashimi (freshly prepared)
Chef’s Carving Board
- Roast Prime Rib Au Jus
- Prime Marinated Skirt Steak
- Fresh Fish
- Whole Roasted Fish
- Smoked Salmon
- Traditional Gravlax
Gourmet Salads
- Fresh Mozzarella
- Deviled Eggs
- Traditional Tomato Onion Salad
- Seasonal Fruit Salad
- Additional Assorted Salads (changes weekly)
Freshly Baked
- Croissants
- Danish
- Fresh Bagels
- Gourmet Muffins
- Triple Cream Brie Almondine
From The Griddle
- Belgian Waffles (prepared to order)
- Silver Dollar Buttermilk Pancakes
- Cheese Blintzes (served with Strawberry Grand Marnier Sauce)
Sides
- Applewood Smoked Bacon
- Potato Hash Browns
- Link Sausages
Omelettes (À La Carte)
“At Rothmann’s, we only use the finest ingredients hand-selected just for you.”
Dessert Bar
- Chocolate Fountain
- Fresh Fruit
- Assorted Mini Pastries
- Variety of Gourmet Cakes & Cookies
Prepared in-house by our Pastry Chef
Every steak is prepared to perfection, whether you like it rare or well done. For those searching best dry-aged steak in East Norwich or USDA Prime steak on Long Island, Rothmanns is the place to visit.
Seafood Delights and Appetizer Favorites
Rothmanns is not just for meat lovers. The restaurant offers an impressive seafood menu featuring high-quality, fresh ingredients.
Seafood and starters include:
- Lobster and Shrimp Bisque
- Maryland Crab Cakes
- Grilled Scottish Salmon
- Sesame Crusted Ahi Tuna
Each dish is carefully crafted to complement the steakhouse menu. Guests looking for a seafood restaurant in East Norwich or steakhouse with lobster and crab cakes on Long Island will feel at home.
Award-Winning Beverage Pairings
Drink lovers are in for a treat. Rothmanns features an award-winning drinks list with more than 800 carefully selected labels. Whether you enjoy bold reds or crisp whites, there is a perfect pairing for every dish.
Holiday Cocktails
| Cocktail Name | Price | Description |
| High Fashioned | $18 | Michter’s Rye, Leopold Bros Tart Cherry Liqueur, Aztec Chocolate Bitters, Orange Zest |
| Uncle Walt’s At It Again | $18 | Vanilla Vodka, Egg Nog, St. Elisabeth Allspice Dram, Nutmeg |
| Cozy by the Fireside | $18 | Clyde Mays Single Barrel Bourbon*, Vicario Monk’s Secret Liqueur, Brown Sugar, Citrus |
| Green Mountain Maple | $21 | Buffalo Trace Bourbon, Tanqueray Gin, Pure Maple Syrup, Lemon, Whiskey Smoked Sugar Rim, Slab Bacon Garnish |
| La Passione of Count Camillo Negroni | $18 | Agricolo Evra Gin, Istine Vermouth di Radda, Campari |
| Widow’s Kiss | $18 | Clear Creek Apple Brandy, Yellow Chartreuse, Benedictine, Bitters |
| Rothmann’s Sidecar | $18 | Martel VS Cognac, Orchard Pear Liqueur, Lemon, Superfine Sugar Rim |
| Rosa’s Cantina | $18 | Dos Hombres Mezcal, Tamarind Nectar, Lemon, Orange, Nutmeg |
| The Silk Road | $18 | Cazcabel (additive-free) Reposado Tequila, Sherry, Barrow’s Ginger, Lime, Nutmeg |
| Vegas on a Foggy Night | $18 | Glengoyne 10-year Single Malt Scotch, Braulio, Rhubarb Bitters, Mint |
| My Favorite Things | $18 | Ito’s Vodka, Barrow’s Ginger, Jericho Farms Apple Cider, Velvet Falernum, Lemon |
This Cocktail program places Rothmanns among the best restaurants in East Norwich for drink pairing and premium selections.
Elegant Atmosphere and Private Dining Options
Step into the warm and elegant dining rooms of Rothmanns. The rich wood decor and ambient lighting create a comfortable and luxurious experience for all guests.
Host Your Event at Rothmann’s
Where Every Occasion Becomes Unforgettable
Exceptional Events, Perfectly Executed
Rothmann’s Steakhouse specializes in creating memorable experiences, from intimate gatherings to large celebrations. Every detail receives expert attention to ensure flawless execution.
Why Rothmann’s Stands Out
- Custom Menus: World-class cuisine tailored to specific preferences
- Expert Wine Pairings: Knowledgeable sommeliers assist with perfect selections
- Impeccable Service: Meticulous attention to every aspect of the event
Start Planning Today
Banquet Manager Benoit Thomas handles all arrangements:
📞 516-922-2500
For special occasions, Rothmanns offers private dining rooms:
Event Package Options
Flexible options for every occasion:
- Bronze Package
- Silver Package
- Gold Package
- White Gold Package
- Platinum Package
- Diamond Package
- Saturday Afternoon Package
Additional Options
- Menu Enhancements
- Private Dining Rooms
Begin the Process
Whether you are planning a birthday, anniversary, or company event, Rothmanns offers the most elegant private dining options in East Norwich, Long Island.
Quick Guide About Rothmann’s Steakhouse
| Category | Details |
| Rating | 4.4 (⭐⭐⭐⭐) out of (1,208 reviews) |
| Price Range | $50–100 per person (reported by 321 people) |
| Cuisine Type | Steakhouse |
| Description | Formal landmark that once hosted Theodore Roosevelt, offering steaks, brunch & a buzzing bar scene |
| Services | Dine-in · Takeaway · No-contact delivery |
| Address | 6319 Northern Blvd, East Norwich, NY 11732, United States (RFV8+2H East Norwich, New York) |
| Hours | 5–10 pm |
| Reservations | Find a table |
| Order Online | Place an order |
| Website | For up-to-date menus and prices, visit the official website here. |
| Phone | +1 516-922-2500 |
Directions, Hours, and Contact Info
📍 Address: 6319 Northern Blvd, East Norwich, NY 11732
📞 Phone: (516) 922-2500
🌐 Make a Reservation Online
🕒 Hours of Operation:
- Monday to Thursday: 5 PM to 10 PM
- Friday and Saturday: 5 PM to 11 PM
- Sunday Brunch: 10:30 AM to 3 PM
- Sunday Dinner: 4:30 PM to 9 PM
Location on Map:
Google Maps and clear directions can help visitors find the location easily. Consistent business information across the web helps improve visibility in local search.
Rothmann’s Steakhouse Reviews
Overall Google Reviews: 4.4 / 5 (⭐⭐⭐⭐) From 1,208 reviewers
i) Dennis G: (⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐) (11-09-2025)
Dined in for Dinner | Spent: Over $100 | 5 Months Ago
You do not have to travel into the city to enjoy a high-quality steakhouse. Rothmanns has everything you could want, minus the crowd of tourists. It is a classic steakhouse that should be at the top of the list for any serious steak lover on Long Island. Whether you are celebrating a birthday, hosting a business dinner, or closing out tax season, this place is always worth the trip.
Food: 5/5
Service: 5/5
Atmosphere: 4/5
ii) Joann Dicarlo: 5/5 (⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐) (01-12-2025)
Dined in | 3 Months Ago
Our group of four all ordered steaks. One of us had the ribeye and absolutely loved it—already planning a return visit. Two others tried the American Wagyu strip steak but felt it was a bit overcooked and needed more seasoning. The filet mignon, however, was perfectly prepared, and the Scottish salmon was equally excellent.
The waitstaff were professional and attentive, and the ambiance was elegant yet relaxed. The whiskey selection was impressive, and the dirty martini I ordered was hands down one of the best I have had.
Food: 5/5
Service: 5/5
Atmosphere: 5/5
Noise Level: Quiet and easy to hold a conversation
Perfect For: All group sizes
Wait Time: We were seated right away
Seating: Indoor dining, bar seating, and booths available
Parking: Free onsite parking lot
For more reviews and ratings, visit Google Reviews.
Frequently Asked Questions About Rothmann’s Steakhouse
Q: Do I need a reservation to eat at Rothmanns?
A: Reservations are recommended, especially on weekends and holidays.
Q: What is the dress code at Rothmanns?
A: Business casual. Dress nicely for the occasion.
Q: Are there vegetarian options on the menu?
A: Yes, including fresh salads, pasta, and vegetable sides.
Q: Can I host a private event at Rothmanns?
A: Absolutely. Both private dining rooms can be reserved for events.
Q: Does Rothmanns offer brunch?
A: Yes. Sunday brunch is served from 10:30 AM to 3 PM.
Q: Is there parking available?
A: Yes. Free parking is available onsite.
Stay Connected with Rothmanns Online
Stay updated on seasonal menus, wine tastings, and special promotions:
- Instagram: @rothmannssteakhouse
- Facebook: @Rothmanns Steakhouse
Sharing customer experiences and food images helps build trust and community engagement.
Final Thoughts – Reserve Your Table at Rothmanns Today
From world-class steaks and fresh seafood to fine wines and private dining rooms, Rothmanns Steakhouse sets the standard for upscale dining in East Norwich, Long Island.
👉 Reserve your table now and enjoy a memorable meal in one of Long Island’s most iconic restaurants.
Please also read articles about the NYC restaurants:
- Alligator Lounge Williamsburg: The Ultimate Pizza Party in NYC
- Barbalu Brooklyn: Top Italian Restaurant in Brooklyn with Great Reviews
- Skinny’s Cantina on the Hudson: The Hottest Mexican Spot in NYC
- Ellen’s Stardust Diner: The Ultimate NYC Broadway Dining Experience
- Ali’s Trinbago Roti Shop: Why It’s a Must-Try for Roti Lovers
- Reggianos Milford CT: Why It’s the Best Italian Spot in Town
- Aperibar: Why It’s the Hottest Spot for Cocktails and Bites
- Hotel Delmano: The Ultimate Cocktail Experience in NYC
- Franchia Vegan Cafe: Why It’s NYC’s Best Vegan Spot You Need to Try
- Banzarbar: NYC’s Best Kept Secret for Creative Cocktails
- Kyma Hudson Yards: Why It’s NYC’s Best Greek Restaurant Right Now
- Lillie’s Victorian Establishment: NYC’s Most Unique Pub Experience
- Bowl 360 Astoria: Why It’s Astoria’s Best Healthy Eating Destination
I’m Sada, the founder of TripGuiderz.com. Since 2019, I’ve been crafting travel guides and blog posts to help readers plan smarter adventures. Let’s explore the world together!
