Shullsburg Creamery is a proud Wisconsin-based cheese company that has been delighting cheese lovers for generations. Known for its traditional cheese-making methods, premium ingredients, and small-town values, the creamery has become a favorite across the Midwest and beyond.
In my observations, their commitment to heritage and taste truly sets them apart.
A Rich Legacy of Cheese Craftsmanship
Shullsburg Creamery has been producing cheese since the 1930s. Based in the historic town of Shullsburg, Wisconsin, the company has remained committed to the art of cheese-making. What started as a small dairy endeavor has grown into a nationally recognized brand.
They are well-known for their authentic cheese curds, aged cheddar, Swiss, colby jack, and specialty blends. Every bite reflects the traditions of Wisconsin dairy excellence.
What Makes Shullsburg Creamery Unique?
What really sets Shullsburg Creamery apart from others?
- High-Quality Milk: Only fresh, top-grade milk from local Wisconsin farms is used.
- Traditional Cheese-Making Techniques: They stick to time-honored processes for real, satisfying flavor.
- No Artificial Hormones: Their milk is rBST-free, meaning the cows are not treated with artificial growth hormones.
- Small-Batch Production: Making cheese in smaller batches helps maintain better taste and quality.
- Vacuum-Sealed Packaging: Keeps the cheese fresh longer without compromising its natural flavor.
From my experience, these details might sound small, but they add up to make a big difference in taste and quality.
Shullsburg Creamery Cheese Items With Prices
Artisanal Cheeses
| Product Name | Size | Price |
| Blueberry Cheddar | By the pound | $13.91 |
| Blueberry Cheddar | Whole loaf | $26.57 |
| Blueberry Cheddar | 7 oz Chunk | $5.56 |
| Blueberry Cheddar | 8 oz | $6.70 |
| Bourbon Barrel Smoked Cracked Black Pepper Cheddar | By the pound | $13.91 |
| Bourbon Barrel Smoked Cracked Black Pepper Cheddar | Whole loaf | $26.57 |
| Bourbon Barrel Smoked Cracked Black Pepper Cheddar | 7 oz Chunk | $5.56 |
| Bourbon Barrel Smoked Cracked Black Pepper Cheddar | 8 oz | $6.70 |
| Buffalo Wing Cheddar | 7 oz Chunk | $5.56 |
| Buffalo Wing Cheddar | 8 oz | $6.70 |
| Buffalo Wing Cheddar Cheese | By the pound | $13.91 |
| Buffalo Wing Cheddar Cheese | Whole loaf | $26.57 |
Brewster House Spreads
| Product Name | Price |
| Brewster House – White Sharp Cheddar Spread | $6.57 |
| Brewster House Bacon Cheddar Spread | $6.57 |
| Brewster House Cheddar Beer Spread | $6.57 |
| Brewster House Chipotle Pepper Spread | $6.57 |
| Brewster House Garlic Spread | $6.57 |
| Brewster House Hickory Smoked Spread | $6.57 |
| Brewster House Horseradish Spread | $6.57 |
| Brewster House Mild Queso Dip | $6.57 |
| Brewster House Plum Wine Spread | $6.57 |
| Brewster House Sharp Cheddar Spread | $6.57 |
| Brewster House Spinach Spread | $6.57 |
| Brewster House Tomato Basil Spread | $6.57 |
Butter
| Product Name | Price |
| Butter Quarters | $6.70 |
Cheddar Curds
| Product Name | Price |
| Cheddar Cheese Curd – Buffalo Wing Spice | $8.34 |
| Cheddar Cheese Curd – Chipotle | $8.34 |
| Cheddar Cheese Curd – Dill | $8.34 |
| Cheddar Cheese Curd – Garlic and Chive | $8.34 |
| Cheddar Cheese Curd – Hickory Smoked | $8.34 |
| Cheddar Cheese Curd – Jalapeno | $8.34 |
| Cheddar Cheese Curd – Mixed (Yellow & White) | $8.34 |
| Cheddar Cheese Curd – White | $8.34 |
| Cheddar Cheese Curd – Yellow | $8.34 |
Cheese by the Pound
| Product Name | Price |
| 10 Year Aged Cheddar (by the pound) | $20.24 |
| 4 Year Aged Cheddar (by the pound) | $14.92 |
| 5 Year Aged Cheddar (by the pound) | $15.18 |
| Aged Brick Schmear (by the pound) | $15.68 |
| Baby Swiss Cheese (by the pound) | $11.00 |
| Blueberry Cheddar (by the pound) | $13.91 |
| Bourbon Barrel Smoked Cracked Black Pepper Cheddar (by the pound) | $13.91 |
| Buffalo Wing Cheddar Cheese (by the pound) | $13.91 |
| Chocolate Cheese (by the pound) | $18.59 |
| Colby Cheese (by the pound) | $10.11 |
| Colby Jack (by the pound) | $10.11 |
| Colby Jack Longhorn Full Horn (by the pound) | $8.72 |
Cold Pack Spreads
| Product Name | Price |
| Cheddar Bacon Cold Pack 13 oz. | $6.70 |
| Cheddar Bacon Cold Pack 7 oz. | $4.29 |
| Cheddar Garden Vegetable Cold Pack 7 oz. | $4.29 |
| Cheddar Garlic Cold Pack 7 oz. | $4.29 |
| Cheddar Honey Sriracha Cold Pack 7 oz. | $4.29 |
| Cheddar Horseradish Cold Pack 13 oz. | $6.70 |
| Cheddar Horseradish Cold Pack 7 oz. | $4.29 |
| Cheddar Port Wine Cold Pack 13 oz. | $6.70 |
| Cheddar Port Wine Cold Pack 7 oz. | $4.29 |
| Sharp Cheddar Cold Pack 13 oz. | $6.70 |
| Sharp Cheddar Cold Pack 7 oz. | $4.29 |
| Smoked Cheddar Cold Pack 13 oz. | $6.70 |
Countryside BBQ Sauce
| Product Name | Price |
| Countryside BBQ Sauce 1 gal | $36.70 |
| Countryside BBQ Sauce 20.5 oz | $7.92 |
Exact Weight (retail) Cheese
| Product Name | Price |
| Baby Swiss 10 oz. | $6.95 |
| Blueberry Cheddar 8 oz. | $6.70 |
| Bourbon Barrel Smoked Cracked Black Pepper Cheddar 8 oz. | $6.70 |
| Brun-Uusto – Garlic | $9.61 |
| Brun-Uusto – Jalapeno | $9.61 |
| Brun-Uusto – Original | $9.61 |
| Brun-Uusto – Pizza Blend | $9.61 |
| Buffalo Wing Cheddar 8 oz. | $6.70 |
| Carolina Reaper Cheese 8 oz. | $7.20 |
| Cheese N Bacon 8 oz. | $5.56 |
| Cheese N Garlic 8 oz. | $5.56 |
| Cheese N Onion 8 oz. | $5.56 |
Flavored Cheese by the Pound
| Product Name | Price |
| Cheese N Bacon (by the pound) | $8.09 |
| Cheese N Garlic (by the pound) | $8.09 |
| Cheese N Onion (by the pound) | $8.09 |
| Cheese N Salami (by the pound) | $8.09 |
| Horseradish Cheese (by the pound) | $8.09 |
| Hot Pepper Cheese (by the pound) | $8.09 |
| Super Hot Pepper Cheese (by the pound) | $8.09 |
| Swiss N Caraway (by the pound) | $8.09 |
Gift Boxes
| Product Name | Price |
| Artisan Collection | $50.00 |
| Family Size Cheese and Sausage Tray | $107.00 |
| Holiday Favorites | $55.00 |
| Large Shullsburg Assortment | $88.00 |
| Shullsburg Snack Pack Tray | $56.00 |
| Signature Cheese Wheel – Baby Swiss | $55.00 |
| Signature Cheese Wheel – Blue Cheese | $60.00 |
| Small Tray Assortment | $67.00 |
| Taste of Wisconsin | $55.00 |
Italia Brand Cheeses
| Product Name | Price |
| Parmesan Shaker | $5.56 |
| Shaved Parmesan | $4.42 |
| Shredded Asiago | $4.42 |
| Shredded Parmesan | $4.29 |
| String Cheese (8 oz.) | $5.94 |
| String Cheese Family Pack | $10.75 |
| String Cheese Smoked | $6.32 |
Mini Moons
| Product Name | Price |
| Colby Cheese 8oz Mini Moon | $5.18 |
| Colby Jack Cheese 8oz Mini Moon | $5.18 |
| Farmer Cheese 8oz Mini Moon | $5.18 |
| Mild Cheddar Cheese 8oz Mini Moon | $5.18 |
| Pepper Jack Cheese 8oz Mini Moon | $5.18 |
| Peppered Colby Jack Cheese 8oz Mini Moon | $5.18 |
Smoked Cheese
Smoked cheeses have become increasingly popular, and our line of hickory smoked cheeses leads the category! We slowly hickory smoke our cheeses to fully infuse the flavor throughout. Great taste with a golden, creamy finish!
| Product Name | Price |
| Hickory Smoked Gouda | $5.81 |
| Hickory Smoked Provolone | $8.22 |
| Hickory Smoked Swiss and Cheddar | $5.68 |
| Hickory Smoked X Sharp Cheddar | $7.20 |
| Smoked Gouda (by the pound) | $10.11 |
| Smoked Gouda (Whole Loaf) | $49.99 |
| Smoked Swiss (by the pound) | $10.75 |
| Smoked Swiss (Whole Loaf) | $62.01 |
| Smokey Cheddar (by the pound) | $12.65 |
| Smokey Cheddar (Whole Loaf) | $23.15 |
| Smokey Swiss N Cheddar (by the pound) | $12.65 |
| Smokey Swiss N Cheddar (Whole Loaf) | $23.15 |
Whole Loaf Cheese
Buy in bulk and save! Our cheeses are available by the whole loaf or horn at a discounted price.
| Product Name | Price |
| 10 Year Aged Cheddar (Whole Loaf) | $75.94 |
| 4 Year Aged Cheddar (Whole Loaf) | $59.61 |
| 5 Year Aged Cheddar (Whole Loaf) | $64.54 |
| Aged Brick Schmear (Whole Loaf) | $75.94 |
| Baby Swiss Cheese (Whole Loaf) | $43.03 |
| Blueberry Cheddar (Whole Loaf) | $26.57 |
| Bourbon Barrel Smoked Cracked Black Pepper Cheddar (Whole Loaf) | $26.57 |
| Buffalo Wing Cheddar Cheese (Whole Loaf) | $26.57 |
| Cheese N Bacon (Whole Loaf) | $32.27 |
| Cheese N Garlic (Whole Loaf) | $32.27 |
| Cheese N Onion (Whole Loaf) | $32.27 |
| Cheese N Salami (Whole Loaf) | $32.27 |
How Cheese is Made at Shullsburg Creamery
Ever wonder how Shullsburg Creamery makes its cheese so good? Here’s a simplified step-by-step look:
- Milk Collection: Fresh milk arrives daily from trusted Wisconsin dairy farms.
- Pasteurization: The milk is gently heated to kill harmful bacteria.
- Curdling: Enzymes and cultures are added to help the milk separate into curds and whey.
- Cutting and Cooking: The curds are cut and slowly heated to remove moisture.
- Pressing and Shaping: Curds are formed into blocks or specialty shapes.
- Aging (for Some Varieties): Cheeses like cheddar are aged to develop stronger flavors.
- Packaging: Cheese is vacuum-sealed to lock in freshness and flavor.
Every step is handled with care to ensure a delicious final product.
How to Choose the Best Cheese from Shullsburg
Picking the right cheese doesn’t have to be tricky. Here’s a quick guide to help you:
- For quick snacking, choose cheese curds or mild cheddar.
- For melty goodness, go with Colby Jack or Monterey Jack.
- For a bold bite, aged cheddar (like their 2-year or 5-year version) is perfect.
- For party platters, mix things up with Swiss, Muenster, and cheddar blocks.
Pro Tip: Always check the packaging date and storage directions for the freshest experience.
10 Delicious Recipes Using Shullsburg Cheese
Here are 10 tasty ways to enjoy Shullsburg Cheese at home:
- Classic Mac and Cheese: Combine Colby Jack and cheddar for creamy perfection.
- Grilled Cheese Sandwich: Swiss and cheddar make a gooey duo.
- Cheesy Quesadillas: Use Monterey Jack for a stretchy, melty filling.
- Cheddar Broccoli Soup: Add sharp cheddar for rich flavor.
- Stuffed Burgers: Press cheddar into patties for a cheesy surprise.
- Homemade Pizza: Mix mozzarella with smoked Gouda for a next-level pie.
- Breakfast Burritos: Try pepper jack for a spicy morning boost.
- Cheese Fondue: Melt Swiss and Havarti together for a creamy dip.
- Cheese-Stuffed Meatballs: A fun twist with melted cheddar inside.
- Cheese & Fruit Platter: Combine their unique blends with apples, grapes, or pears.
5 Best Recommended Dishes Featuring Shullsburg Creamery Cheese
Whether you are shopping for home use or preparing a party platter, here are five must-try Shullsburg cheese products and ways to enjoy them:
1. Grilled Cheese with Aged Cheddar
A classic American sandwich upgraded with Shullsburg’s sharp cheddar. Melts perfectly and tastes divine.
2. Cheddar Cheese Curds
A fan favorite! These fresh, squeaky curds are perfect for snacking or frying.
“Their cheddar curds are hands down the best – so fresh and squeaky!” – Google Review
3. Swiss and Ham Roll-Ups
Create tasty wraps using Shullsburg Swiss for picnics or lunchboxes. Adds a nutty, rich flavor.
4. Mac and Cheese with Colby Jack
Use Colby Jack cheese for a creamier, kid-friendly mac and cheese experience.
5. Charcuterie Board with Mixed Blocks
Combine their cheddar, Swiss, and specialty blends with fruits and nuts for an elegant snack platter.
“Tastes just like the cheese we used to get from the farm. Pure and delicious!” – Facebook Review
Where to Buy Shullsburg Creamery Cheese
You can purchase Shullsburg products through:
- Their official website: Shullsburgcreamery
- Retail stores across the Midwest and nationwide
- Local delis and grocery chains (availability may vary)
Their site offers a product locator to help you find the nearest shop.
Shullsburg Creamery Locations & Hours
Water Street Place
| Category | Details |
| Type | Cheese shop |
| Google Rating | 4.7 (227 reviews) |
| Address | 208 W Water St, Shullsburg, WI 53586 |
| Location | Floor 1, Water Street Place |
| Website | For online orders, visit here. |
| Phone Number | (608) 965-3855 |
| Hours | 10 AM–5 PM |
| Services | Curbside pickup |
Shullsburg Creamery (Dairy Supplier location):
| Category | Details |
| Business Name | Shullsburg Creamery |
| Rating | 5.0 (17 reviews) |
| Type | Dairy supplier |
| Address | 102 Bader Way, Shullsburg, WI 53586 |
| Website | For online orders, visit here. |
| Phone Number | (608) 965-4485 |
| Hours | 8 AM–4:30 PM |
Locations on Map:
Shullsburg Creamery Reviews
Overall Rating: 4.7/5 (⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐) Based on 6 reviews. Tripadvisor.
5 Other Cheese Brands You Might Like
If you enjoy Shullsburg Creamery, you might also enjoy these reputable cheese makers:
1. Carr Valley Cheese
- Website: carrvalleycheese.com
- Google Rating: 4.8 (⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐) (based on hundreds of reviews)
- Overview: Carr Valley is a family-owned operation producing award-winning artisan cheeses in Wisconsin. Known for creative flavors and traditional methods.
2. Hook’s Cheese Company
- Website: hookscheese.com
- Google Rating: 4.7 (⭐⭐⭐⭐)
- Overview: Famous for their aged cheddars and blue cheese. Their 10-year cheddar is legendary.
3. Renard’s Cheese
- Website: renardscheese.com
- Google Rating: 4.8 (⭐⭐⭐⭐)
- Overview: Offers a wide variety of cheese in Door County, WI. Family-run and known for curds and spreads.
4. Beehive Cheese
- Website: beehivecheese.com
- Google Rating: 4.6 (⭐⭐⭐⭐)
- Overview: Utah-based artisan cheese company known for rubbed-rind cheeses and bold flavors.
5. BelGioioso Cheese
- Website: belgioioso.com
- Google Rating: 4.7 (⭐⭐⭐⭐)
- Overview: An Italian-style Wisconsin cheese producer offering fresh mozzarella, parmesan, and provolone.
Common Questions About Shullsburg Creamery
Q: Where is Shullsburg Creamery located?
A: The creamery is located in Shullsburg, Wisconsin, a small town with a strong dairy heritage.
Q: What types of cheese do they offer?
A: They offer cheddar, curds, Swiss, Monterey Jack, Colby, Muenster, and blended options.
Q: Can I visit Shullsburg Creamery for a tour or tasting?
A: While Shullsburg Creamery focuses on cheese production and distribution, public tours or tastings are not regularly offered. Their products are available online and in retail stores.
Q: Do they use artificial growth hormones in their cheese?
A: No. Their cheese is made using milk from cows not treated with rBST.
Q: What makes their cheese taste so authentic?
A: It’s the combination of local milk, small-batch production, and traditional methods.
Final Thoughts from the Author
In my observations, Shullsburg Creamery stands out because it respects tradition while still offering accessible, high-quality products. The brand captures the heart of Wisconsin dairy culture. If you are looking for real cheese with real taste, Shullsburg delivers every time.
Whether you are a casual snacker, a home chef, or a die-hard cheese fan, give them a try—you will taste the difference.
Please also read articles about the following spots:
