Imagine sinking your teeth into a perfectly crafted, generously layered Chicago-style pizza while savoring a cold, expertly selected craft brew each element complementing the other in a moment of pure, unhurried dining pleasure. That is not just a fantasy. That is the signature Old Chicago Pizza Taproom experience, waiting for you every single visit.
Pizza holds a uniquely powerful place in American dining culture. According to the Pizza Industry Council, Americans consume approximately 3 billion pizzas annually, with craft and specialty pizza experiences driving the fastest growth segment as discerning diners increasingly seek quality, authenticity, and culinary artistry over fast-casual convenience.
Founded in 1976 in Boulder, Colorado, Old Chicago Pizza Taproom has spent nearly five decades perfecting the art of combining exceptional, handcrafted pizza with an outstanding rotating craft beer selection, a pairing philosophy that has earned it a fiercely loyal following across its numerous locations nationwide. With an impressive rotating tap selection featuring over 30 craft beers at many locations, Old Chicago stands as a genuine destination for both food and beverage connoisseurs alike.
Every dish emerging from Old Chicago’s kitchen reflects a deep, genuine commitment to bold flavors, premium ingredients, and masterful culinary craftsmanship from their iconic deep-dish creations to their innovative seasonal menu additions.
Whether you’re a longtime local regular or a first-time visitor discovering this beloved taproom for the very first time, Old Chicago Pizza Taproom delivers a consistently outstanding combination of mouthwatering food, exceptional drinks, and a warmly welcoming atmosphere that makes every visit feel like a genuine celebration worth repeating.
What is Old Chicago Pizza Taproom?
For years, Old Chicago Pizza Taproom has been a go-to destination for pizza lovers. Known for its hand-crafted pizzas, this restaurant combines the art of pizza-making with a relaxing taproom feel.
With locations spread across the United States, it’s become a beloved brand, offering a wide variety of creative pizzas and an impressive craft beer selection.
Old Chicago Pizza Taproom Menu
🍕 Unreal Pizza Deals
| Menu Item | Price | Description | Notes |
| Party Pack for 4 | $35.99 | Taproom Starter, Large Pizza, 6 Inch Big Cookie | Calories per slice/piece |
| Pizza Party To-Go | $150.09 | Cheesy Dippin’ Strips, Salad Platter, 3 Large Pizzas, 2 Big Cookizzas | Serves 8–10 |
| Party Pack for 6 | $71.99 | Taproom Starter, 2 Large Pizzas, 9 Inch Big Cookie | Calories per slice/piece |
🍽️ Starters
| Item | Price | Calories | Description |
| Sicilian Pepperoni Rolls™ | $13.79 | 1265 Cal | Dough, pepperoni, green onions, cheese, red sauce |
| Buffalo Chicken Rolls | $13.79 | 1170 Cal | Chicken, Buffalo sauce, mozzarella, celery, bleu cheese |
| Twisted Tenders | $13.79 | 930 Cal | Buttermilk-marinated chicken, seasoned flour, 2 sauces |
| Mozzarella Sticks | $11.39 | 630 Cal | Breaded, fried, red sauce |
| Italian Nachos | $16.79 | 2230 Cal | Pasta chips, mozzarella, sausage, pepperoni, red sauce |
| Spinach Artichoke Dip | $13.79 | 795 Cal | Spinach, artichokes, mozzarella, parmesan, pasta chips |
| Bavarian Pretzel Sticks | $11.99 | 950 Cal | Served with Guinness mustard beer cheese sauce |
| Fried Pickles | $11.39 | 1155 Cal | Beer battered, spicy, with ranch or Thai chili sauce |
| Cheesy Dippin’ Strips | $11.99 | 215 Cal | Thick crust, mozzarella, garlic butter, seasoning, red sauce |
| Queso Bueno (Limited Time) | $13.79 | — | Beer queso, spinach, tomato, hot sauce, wonton chips |
🍗 Wings
| Item | Price | Calories | Description |
| Bone-In Chicken Wings Short | $13.19 | 390 Cal | Twice-cooked wings, signature sauces/dry rubs |
| Boneless Wings Short | $11.39 | 420 Cal | Boneless breaded wings, signature sauces/dry rubs |
| Bone-In Chicken Wings Tall | $20.39 | 780 Cal | Larger portion, same as above |
| Boneless Wings Tall | $16.19 | 845 Cal | Larger boneless portion |
| Keg of Wings | $32.99 | — | Double the wings, double the sauce |
🍕 Pizza
| Pizza | Price | Description |
| Craft Your Own Pizza | Priced by add-ons | Choose crust & toppings |
| Double Deckeroni™ | Priced by add-ons | 2x pepperoni, parmesan, hot sauce, parsley |
| Meat Me™ | Priced by add-ons | Sausages, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, olives, basil |
| Chicago 7™ | Priced by add-ons | Pepperoni, sausage, red onion, olives, peppers, mushrooms |
| The Classic | Priced by add-ons | Pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, roasted garlic |
| Farmer’s Daughter Pizza | Priced by add-ons | Mozzarella, sundried tomato, pesto, arugula, balsamic drizzle |
| Thai Pie | Priced by add-ons | Thai chili sauce, cheeses, chicken, veggies, sesame, teriyaki |
| Top It Off (sauces) | Priced by add-ons | 30 – 255 Cal. Select sauce for drizzle or dunking |
| Veggie 7 | Priced by add-ons | Onion, bell pepper, mushroom, olives, artichokes, red pepper |
| Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza | Priced by add-ons | Ranch sauce, chicken, bacon, mozzarella, green onion, Ranch drizzle |
| Nacho Average Pizza (Limited) | Priced by add-ons | Queso sauce, beef/chicken, tomato, onion, jalapeño, mozzarella |
Calzones
| Item | Price | Calories | Description |
| Craft Your Own Calzone | $11.99 | – | A blend of mozzarella, ricotta. Choose your favorite fresh toppings. |
| Chicago 7™ Calzone | $16.19 | 1150 Cal | Pepperoni, Italian sausage, red onions, black olives, green peppers, sliced mushrooms, mozzarella, ricotta. |
| Chicago Fire Calzone | $16.79 | 1560 Cal | Pepperoni, sweet Italian sausage, red peppers, red onions, pepperoncini, mozzarella, ricotta, jalapeño crust. |
Entrées
| Item | Price | Calories | Description |
| Chicken Parmesan | $17.99 | 1035 Cal | Basil and parmesan crusted chicken breast, mozzarella, penne, fresh basil & signature red sauce |
| Chicken Pesto Alfredo | $17.99 | 1165 Cal | Penne Alfredo, applewood chicken, broccoli, diced tomatoes, pesto, shaved parmesan |
| Spaghetti & Meatballs | $16.19 | 1165 Cal | Meatballs over spaghetti, red sauce, basil, parmesan |
| Chicken & Bacon Mac | $16.19 | 1035 Cal | Cavatappi, beer cheese sauce, applewood chicken, peppered bacon |
| Oh My Spaghetti Pie | $16.79 | – | Spaghetti with Alfredo, baked with Italian cheeses, choice of marinara or Alfredo |
| Spaghetti Pie with Meatballs | $20.39 | – | Same as above with two meatballs |
| Spaghetti Pie with Chicken | $20.39 | – | Same as above with applewood smoked chicken |
| Twisted Tenders Meal | $17.39 | – | 6 fried tenders, fries, choice of 2 sauces |
| Southwest Chicken Pasta (LTO) | $16.19 | – | Penne, grilled chicken, peppers/onions, green chile pepper sauce, Pepper Jack cheese |
Handhelds
Served with choice of fries, coleslaw or fresh veggies. Veggie patty available.
| Item | Price | Calories | Description |
| Crafted Beer Burger* | $16.19 | 770 Cal | Burger with lager & mustard beer cheese sauce, crispy onion strings |
| Classic Cheeseburger* | $14.39 | 815 Cal | Burger with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickles & garlic aioli |
| BBQ Bacon Cheeseburger* | $16.19 | 840 Cal | BBQ sauce, American cheese & peppered bacon |
| Chicken Caesar Wrap | $15.59 | 591 Cal | Romaine, applewood chicken, Caesar dressing, parmesan cheese in tortilla |
| Chicken Salad Wrap | $16.79 | 741 Cal | Chicken salad, bacon, lettuce, tomato in flour tortilla |
| Ranchero Quesadilla (LTO) | $15.59 | – | Cheddar, pepper jack, crispy chicken, bacon, peppers & onions, side of spicy ranch |
Salads
| Item | Price | Calories | Description |
| Side Caesar Salad | $5.99 | 275 Cal | Romaine, shaved parmesan, basil croutons, Caesar dressing |
| Side Garden Salad | $5.99 | 105 Cal | Greens, carrots, cucumbers, croutons, tomatoes, choice of dressing |
| Old Chicago Chopped Salad | $16.19 | 475 Cal | Applewood chicken, bacon, bleu cheese, green onions, tomato, creamy herb dressing |
| Blackened Chicken Caesar | $15.59 | 420 Cal | Cajun chicken, romaine, Parmesan, croutons, Caesar dressing |
| Roasted Chicken & Apple Walnut | $16.19 | 665 Cal | Greens, bleu cheese, apples, walnuts, cranberries, applewood chicken, creamy herb dressing |
🧒 Kids Meals
| Item | Price | Calories | Description |
| Chicken Tenders | $7.19 | 550 Cal. | Served with your choice of one side. |
| Mighty Cheeseburger | $7.19 | 485 Cal. | Served with your choice of one side. |
| Kids Build Your Own Pizza | $6.09 | 555 Cal. | Build your own kid-sized version of our Chicago pizza. Choose 2 toppings. |
| Kids Champion Cheese Pizza | $7.19 | 555 Cal. | Kid-sized version of our famous Chicago-style pizza. |
| Spaghetti | $7.19 | 215 Cal. | Served with your choice of one side. |
| Penne Alfredo | $7.19 | 400 Cal. | Served with your choice of one side. |
| Mac N’ Cheese | $7.19 | 405 Cal. | Served with your choice of one side. |
| Spaghetti & 1 Meatball | $8.69 | – | – |
🍰 Dessert
| Item | Price | Description |
| Scratch Made Cookizza | $6.59 | All-butter cookie dough w/ chocolate, baked in deep-dish pan. (Calories per slice) |
| Doughnut Bites | $7.19 | Fried doughnut balls with cinnamon sugar, served w/ fudge & caramel sauce. |
| Triple Chocolate Brownie | $8.99 | Brownie topped with fudge sauce, ice cream, caramel and chocolate drizzle. |
🍟 Sides
| Item | Price | Calories |
| Fries | $4.79 | 270 Cal. |
| Additional Sauces | Varies | – |
| Side of Veggies & Dip | $4.79 | 120 Cal. |
| Tots | $4.79 | – |
| Broccoli w/ Garlic Butter | $5.99 | – |
🥤 Drinks
| Item | Price | Calories | Description |
| Red Bull | $6.09 | 5 – 110 Cal. | Regular, Sugar Free, or Watermelon flavor |
| Fountain Drinks | $3.99 | 0 – 170 Cal. | – |
| Stacked Sodas | $4.79 | – | – |
| Iced Teas | $3.99 | 0 – 115 Cal. | – |
| Lemonades | $3.99 | – | Classic, Strawberry, or Pomegranate |
| Juices | $3.99 | – | Apple, Orange, Tomato, Cranberry, Grapefruit, or Pineapple |
3 Signature Pizzas at Old Chicago Pizza Taproom
Old Chicago Pizza Taproom has established itself as a beloved institution in the world of American pizza, a place where genuine craft, bold creativity, and an unwavering commitment to quality ingredients come together to produce pizzas that are as exciting and memorable as they are deeply satisfying. With a menu that celebrates both timeless classics and innovative new creations, Old Chicago consistently delivers a pizza experience that rewards every visit with something fresh, flavorful, and worth savoring. Here are three signature pizzas that every guest absolutely must try.
1. 🍕 Chicago 7™ — The Ultimate Hearty Pizza Experience
The Chicago 7™ is Old Chicago’s most boldly ambitious and generously conceived signature pizza a magnificent, hearty creation that makes an immediate and powerful statement about what this restaurant believes great pizza should look, taste, and feel like. Loaded with a carefully selected, bold blend of premium meats that deliver layer upon layer of rich, savory depth, the Chicago 7™ is the kind of pizza that commands attention from the moment it arrives at the table and rewards every bite with a deeply satisfying flavor experience that is difficult to find anywhere else.
Complementing the impressive meat blend is a vibrant selection of fresh vegetables that add essential brightness, color, and a welcome balance to the richness of the proteins beneath. This thoughtful combination of bold, savory meat flavors and fresh vegetable notes creates a pizza that achieves something genuinely impressive a perfect harmony of hearty indulgence and fresh, lively flavor that never tips too far in either direction. The Chicago 7™ is the pizza you order when you want something substantial, deeply satisfying, and genuinely representative of Old Chicago’s bold culinary vision at its very best.
2. 🍕 Double Deckeroni™ — A Pepperoni Lover’s Absolute Dream
For anyone who has ever looked at a pepperoni pizza and thought that one layer of that gloriously crispy, spicy, savory cured meat simply was not enough, Old Chicago’s Double Deckeroni™ arrives as the most satisfying and enthusiastic answer imaginable. As its brilliantly descriptive name proudly announces, this exceptional pizza features not one but two generous, overlapping layers of crispy pepperoni a bold, unapologetic doubling down on the ingredient that has made pepperoni pizza one of the most universally beloved food creations in American culinary history.
The magic of the Double Deckeroni™ lies in what happens to those two layers of pepperoni during the baking process. Each slice curls slightly at the edges as it crisps in the heat of the oven, creating those irresistible, cup-shaped pieces that gather pools of flavorful, rendered fat and develop an extraordinary depth of spicy, savory, caramelized flavor that single-layer pepperoni pizzas simply cannot achieve. The contrast between the gloriously crispy outer layer and the slightly softer, more richly flavored layer beneath creates a textural and flavor experience that is genuinely extraordinary and endlessly satisfying for dedicated pepperoni enthusiasts.
3. 🍕 The Italian Beef™ — Chicago’s Most Iconic Sandwich Reimagined
The Italian Beef™ pizza is perhaps the most creative, culturally rooted, and genuinely exciting entry in Old Chicago’s signature pizza collection a brilliant and lovingly executed homage to one of Chicago’s most iconic and fiercely beloved culinary traditions. Inspired directly by the legendary Chicago Italian beef sandwich that has satisfied hungry Chicagoans for generations, this extraordinary pizza takes everything that makes the original sandwich so irresistible and translates it magnificently onto a pizza canvas in a way that feels both entirely natural and completely inspired.
Thinly sliced, expertly seasoned roast beef tender, juicy, and deeply flavorful forms the generous, satisfying foundation of this remarkable pizza. Layered over and around the beef is a vibrant, tangy giardiniera the quintessential Chicago condiment of pickled vegetables and peppers that adds a bright, acidic, spicy complexity that cuts beautifully through the richness of the meat beneath. A generous blanket of creamy, perfectly melted mozzarella ties every element together in a warm, cohesive embrace that transforms individually great components into one irresistible, unified, and utterly memorable pizza experience that celebrates the very best of Chicago food culture.
Why Choose Old Chicago Pizza Taproom?
Old Chicago Pizza Taproom stands out for its unmatched ambiance, unique menu, and focus on community. Here’s why it should be your next dining destination:
- Relaxed Taproom Ambiance: The friendly, welcoming environment makes it easy to unwind while enjoying your meal. Whether you’re with friends or family, the laid-back atmosphere is perfect for casual dining or special occasions.
- Creative Pizza Menu: Old Chicago’s signature pizzas, like the Chicago 7™ and Double Deckeroni™, are full of bold flavors and unique combinations that keep guests coming back for more.
- Extensive Craft Beer Selection: With a rotating selection of craft beers on tap, Old Chicago ensures that there’s a perfect brew to pair with every meal. From light and refreshing to bold and hoppy, you’ll find something to suit your taste.
- Friendly Service: The staff at Old Chicago makes every visit memorable with their warm and attentive service, ensuring that every guest feels right at home.
How to Find an Old Chicago Pizza Taproom Near You?
With multiple locations across the United States, it’s easy to find a nearby Old Chicago Pizza Taproom. Simply visit Old Chicago Pizza Locations to locate the closest restaurant and get ready to enjoy their signature pizzas and craft drinks.
Location on Map:
Join OC Rewards for Exclusive Offers
Want to make your experience even better? OC Rewards gives you access to exclusive deals and discounts. Join today to start earning rewards with every visit. Join OC Rewards to get started!
Quick Guide About Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom
| Type of Restaurant | Pizza Restaurant |
| Google Rating | 4.0 (1,689 reviews) |
| Price Range | $10–20 |
| Website | For the Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom menu with prices, visit the official website here. |
| Call | +1 970-207-9456 |
| Service Options | Serves happy-hour food, Serves great cocktails, Serves vegetarian dishes |
| Address | 4709 S Timberline Rd, Fort Collins, CO 80528, United States |
| Hours | 11 am–1 am |
Old Chicago Pizza Taproom Reviews
Overall Rating: 5/5 (⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐) Based on 156 reviews. Yelp.
🍕 5 Similar Pizza Restaurants to Try if You Love Aurelio’s Pizza
If you’re a fan of the bold flavors and crispy crusts from the Old Chicago Pizza Taproom menu, you’ll definitely want to check out these other amazing pizza spots. Whether you’re in the Chicago area or just looking for that classic Italian-American taste, here are 5 restaurants similar to Old Chicago:
1. Beggar’s Pizza
Another Chicago-area favorite, Beggar’s is all about “laying it on thick” with cheese and toppings. Their pizza is hearty, cheesy, and made for serious pizza lovers.
- 🌐 Menu
- 📍 Multiple Chicagoland locations
- ⭐ Google Rating: 4.3/5 (⭐⭐⭐⭐)
2. Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria
This legendary name offers buttery deep-dish crusts, vine-ripened tomato sauce, and homemade sausage. Though different from Aurelio’s thin crust, it’s a Chicago must-try.
- 🌐 Menu
- 📍 Primarily in Illinois and surrounding states
- ⭐ Google Rating: 4.6/5 (⭐⭐⭐⭐)
3. Nancy’s Pizza
Known for inventing the stuffed pizza, Nancy’s delivers big on flavor and variety. From pan pizza to gluten-free crusts, their menu is loaded with options.
- 🌐 Menu
- 📍 Primarily in Illinois and Georgia
- ⭐ Google Rating: 4.2/5 (⭐⭐⭐⭐)
4. Rosati’s Pizza
A great option for those who love classic Italian flavors. Their menu features hand-tossed pizzas, pastas, wings, and more. Rosati’s offers both thin and deep-dish styles.
- 🌐 Menu
- 📍 Over 200 locations across the U.S.
- ⭐ Google Rating: 4.4/5 (⭐⭐⭐⭐)
5. Giordano’s
Known for their stuffed deep-dish pizza, Giordano’s is another iconic Chicago brand. If you love cheesy, hearty slices with rich tomato sauce, this is a solid alternative.
- 🌐 Menu & Locations
- 📍 Multiple locations across Chicago and nationwide
- ⭐ Google Rating: 4.3/5 (⭐⭐⭐⭐)
FAQ Section
- What is the best pizza at Old Chicago Pizza Taproom?
The Chicago 7™ and Double Deckeroni™ are popular picks, featuring bold, savory flavors that pizza lovers rave about.
- Does Old Chicago offer gluten-free options?
Yes, Old Chicago Pizza Taproom offers gluten-free crust options for many of their pizzas, ensuring everyone can enjoy their signature dishes.
- Can I order online from Old Chicago Pizza Taproom?
Yes, you can order online for pickup or delivery from your nearest Old Chicago Pizza Taproom location.
- How can I join OC Rewards?
You can easily join OC Rewards by visiting their website and signing up to start earning rewards with every visit.
- Are there vegetarian options at Old Chicago Pizza Taproom?
Yes, there are a variety of vegetarian pizza options on the menu, making it a great spot for all dietary preferences.
Conclusion
Old Chicago Pizza Taproom offers a unique dining experience that goes beyond just great food. With hand-crafted pizzas, an impressive selection of craft beers, and a welcoming taproom atmosphere, it’s the perfect place for friends, family, or a night out. Whether you’re enjoying a classic favorite or trying something new, you’re guaranteed a satisfying meal.
Ready to indulge? Browse the full menu and find your nearest location to make your next meal at Old Chicago Pizza Taproom a memorable one.
Please also read articles about the Chicago restaurants:
- Labriola Chicago: The Ultimate Italian Bakery You’ll Love
- Formento’s: Classic Italian Dining with a Modern Twist in Chicago
- Gibsons Steakhouse Chicago: Why It’s the Best Steakhouse in Town
- Hanabusa Cafe: Why It’s the Best Spot for Matcha Lovers in Town
- RH Rooftop Restaurant Oak Brook Menu With Prices 2025: Elegant Dining Above
- Pequod’s Pizza: A Chicago Favorite Known for Its Signature Caramelized Crust
- Nabala Cafe: The Hidden Gem Every Coffee Lover Needs to Try
- Weber’s Bakery: The Best Kept Secret for Artisanal Baked Goods
- MCCB Chicago: A Must-Try Spot for Authentic Mexican Street Food
