Welcome to Polly’s Pies Menu: Where Every Slice Feels Like Home
Looking for a warm, delicious meal that feels like home? Polly’s Pies Restaurant is the perfect place. Born and beloved in Southern California, Polly’s is more than a restaurant. It is a cozy café, a bakery, and a local tradition wrapped into one.
Families and food lovers come together here for comfort food made with heart.
What Is Polly’s Pies? A Local Favorite Since 1968
Founded in 1968 by brothers Eddie and Donald Sheldrake, Polly’s Pies has grown from a single spot into a regional favorite. The mission was simple — serve homemade food in a welcoming space. Today, Polly’s keeps that promise with every dish.
Each location offers a family-style setting, where every meal is filled with warmth and flavor.
Polly’s Pies Menu With Prices
The menu at Polly’s Pies Restaurant is full of all-American favorites. Whether you stop in for breakfast or dinner, you will find something satisfying. Try the signature Chicken Pot Pie, filled with tender chicken and veggies in a rich gravy.
Aloha Specials
| Item | Price | Description |
| Malihini Pancakes | $13.99 | Banana pancakes with pineapple, whipped cream, macadamia nuts, eggs & bacon or sausage. |
| Loco Moco | $13.99 | Rice, burger patty, sunny-side egg, gravy, green onions. Includes muffin or bakery item. |
| Big Kahuna BLT | $13.99 | Bacon, ham, tomato, lettuce, grilled pineapple, teriyaki, garlic aioli on Hawaiian bun. Served with fries. |
| Huli Huli Chicken Bowl | $15.99 | Marinated chicken over herbed rice, veggies, grilled pineapple, and green onions. |
| Malihini Pie Slice | $5.29 | Banana cream pie topped with pineapple, whipped cream, and macadamia nuts. |
| Malihini Pie Whole | $18.99 | Whole banana cream pie with pineapple, whipped cream, and macadamia nuts. |
| Brownie Sundae | $5.99 | Warm brownie, vanilla ice cream, chocolate sauce, whipped cream, almonds, cherry. |
| Banberry® Shortcake | $5.29 | Banana muffin with glazed strawberries and whipped cream – a twist on shortcake. |
Lunch & Munch Combos
| Item | Price | Description |
| Comeback Chicken Sandwich Combo | $11.99 | Fried chicken breast on white bun with lettuce, pickles, and Comeback Sauce. Served with fries. |
| Chicken Quesadilla Combo | $11.99 | Chicken, Jack & Cheddar, bell peppers, onions, cilantro in tortilla. Served with salsa & fruit cup. Add Sour Cream +$1. |
| Half Sandwich & Fries Combo | $11.99 | Choice of half sandwich with fries: Turkey, Avocado, Chicken Salad, Tuna Salad, or Grilled Cheese. |
| Pasta & Salad Combo | $11.99 | Penne pasta in alfredo sauce with a House salad. Add Chicken or Shrimp +$3. |
| Soup & Salad Combo | $11.99 | Creamy Tomato Basil Soup with House salad and dressing of choice. |
Weekday Breakfast Deals
| Item | Price | Description |
| NEW! Pancake Bites Breakfast | $7.99 | Three Pancake Bites with syrup, two eggs, and bacon or sausage. |
| French Toast Combo | $12.49 | Two French toast slices, two eggs, and bacon or sausage links. |
| Country Combo | $9.99 | Biscuits with sausage gravy, two eggs any style, and fresh fruit cup. |
| Early Riser Breakfast | $12.99 | Two eggs, bacon or sausage, breakfast potatoes, and a daily bakery item. |
| Perfect Pancake Breakfast | $10.99 | Two buttermilk pancakes, two eggs, and bacon or sausage links. |
3 for $15 Menu
| Category | Options |
| Starter | Cup of Creamy Tomato Basil Soup or Polly’s House Salad. |
| Entree | – Creamy Pasta (Add Chicken +$3, Shrimp +$3) – NEW! Meatloaf Sandwich – Mega Grilled Cheese – Chicken Fried Steak – Upgrade Options: Salisbury Steak (+$2), Classic Meatloaf (+$2), Grilled Norwegian Salmon (+$4) |
| Pie | Apple, Apple NSA, Custard, Lemon Meringue, or Pie of the Day. |
Breakfast
| Item | Price | Description |
| New Starter! Pancake Bites | $3.49 | 5 Pancake Bites coated in cinnamon sugar with syrup. |
| Double Buttermilk Pancakes | $13.49 | Two pancakes with butter & syrup. Add chocolate chips or blueberries +$1.49. |
| Banana Macadamia Nut Pancakes | $13.99 | Banana pancakes topped with whipped cream & macadamia nuts. |
| Giant Cinnamon Roll French Toast | $12.99 | Grilled cinnamon roll slices in egg batter. |
| French Toast Combo | $12.99 | Two slices of French toast made with fresh baked bread. |
| Triple Breakfast Surprise | $16.99 | 3 pancakes, 3 eggs, 3 sausages or bacon, breakfast potatoes. |
| French Toast Triple Breakfast | $18.99 | Same as above, but with French toast instead of pancakes. |
| Polly’s Breakfast Burrito | $13.99 | Tortilla filled with meat, eggs, hashbrowns, cheese, avocado, & veggies. |
| Avocado Toast with Egg | $12.99 | Sourdough with avocado, tomato, 2 eggs, and salsa. |
| Breakfast Sandwich | $11.99 | Sourdough with meat, hashbrowns, scrambled eggs, cheese, & mayo. |
| A.B.C. Omelette | $15.99 | Avocado, bacon, cheddar, mushrooms, green onions. |
| NEW! Greek Omelette | $15.99 | Artichoke, bell peppers, tomato, olives, oregano, feta. |
| Vegetable Omelette | $13.99 | Seasonal veggies with cheddar cheese & salsa. |
| NEW! Create Your Own Omelette | $13.49+ | Choose egg style, 2 veggies; add meat, cheese, or more veggies. |
| Vegetarian Chorizo Skillet | $15.99 | Eggs, veggies, plant-based chorizo, avocado on potatoes. |
| Have it All Skillet | $15.99 | Eggs, bacon, sausage, veggies, cheese over breakfast potatoes. |
| 2-3-1 Combo | $13.99 | 2 eggs, 3 sausage links or bacon, with potatoes. |
| One Egg Combo | $9.99 | 1 egg, 2 sausages or bacon, with breakfast potatoes. |
| Eggs & Potatoes | $9.99 | 2 eggs with breakfast potatoes. |
| Chicken Fried Steak & Eggs | $16.99 | Country gravy, 2 eggs, and breakfast potatoes. |
| Eggs Benedict | $15.99 | Poached eggs over ham on biscuit with Hollandaise, fruit & potatoes. |
Starters
| Item | Price | Description |
| Southern Pimento Cheese Dip | $7.99 | Chilled house-made dip with green onions, cucumbers, carrots & baguette. |
| Polly’s Crispy Chicken Wings | $11.99 | Choice of BBQ or Buffalo sauce. 9 Wings – $14.99 |
| Beer-Battered Onion Rings | $8.49 | Thick-cut onions served with Comeback Sauce. |
| Mozzarella Sticks | $8.99 | Golden-fried cheese sticks served with marinara sauce. |
Soups & Salads
| Item | Price | Description |
| Cup Creamy Tomato Basil Soup | $4.99 | Tomato soup with cream, basil, Parmesan, and croutons. |
| Bowl Creamy Tomato Basil Soup | $8.49 | Larger portion of creamy tomato basil soup with toppings. |
| Soup Bowl & Salad Combo | $10.99 | Bowl of soup with Polly’s House or Caesar salad. |
| Asian Chicken Salad | $14.99 | Grilled chicken, greens, mandarin oranges, crispy wontons & sesame dressing. |
| Turkey Cobb Salad | $15.49 | Turkey, bacon, egg, avocado, bleu cheese, and veggies over lettuce. |
| Caesar Salad | $9.99 | Romaine, croutons, Parmesan, Caesar dressing. Add Chicken +$3.99, Salmon +$7.99, Shrimp +$5.99 |
| Side Caesar Salad | $4.99 | Smaller Caesar with garlic Parmesan bread. |
| Polly’s House Salad | $5.99 | Mixed greens, tomato, cucumber, carrots, onion & croutons. |
| Bleu Cheese Wedge | $6.99 | Iceberg wedge with bacon, bleu cheese, tomatoes, and dressing. Add to entrée +$5.99 |
Sandwiches menu
| Item | Price | Description |
| NEW! BBQ Prime Rib Sandwich | $18.99 | Sliced prime rib, Sriracha-Ale mustard, BBQ, onions, Jack cheese & arugula on bun. |
| NEW! Comeback Chicken Sandwich | $12.99 | Fried chicken breast with pickles, lettuce & Comeback Sauce on a white bun. |
| Prime Rib French Dip | $16.99 | Prime rib on baguette with horseradish aioli & au jus. |
| Old-Fashioned Chicken Salad | $11.99 | Chicken salad with walnuts, onions, relish & mayo on raisin walnut bread. |
| Famous Tuna Salad Sandwich | $11.99 | Tuna, egg, onions, celery, and mayo on white bread. |
| Garlic Aioli Turkey Sandwich | $13.99 | Oven-roasted turkey, garlic aioli, tomato, lettuce & Jack cheese on sourdough. Add Avocado or Bacon +$2.49 |
| Avocado and Friends Sandwich | $10.99 | Avocado, tomato, cucumber, onion, lettuce & cheese on kracked wheat bread. |
| Half Sandwich Combo | $10.99 | Half sandwich with soup, house salad, or side Caesar. Choose from 5 options. |
| California Tuna Melt | $13.99 | Tuna salad, avocado, tomato, lettuce, mayo & Cheddar on grilled sourdough. |
| Mega Grilled Cheese | $10.99 | Jack, Cheddar, Swiss & American on sourdough with garlic Parmesan spread. Add Avocado or Bacon +$2.49, Tomato +$0.49 |
Burgers menu
| Item | Price | Description |
| NEW! Create Your Own Burger | $12.49+ | 1/3 lb burger with pickles, lettuce, and choice of protein, bun, sauce & toppings. Served with fries or coleslaw. Custom add-ons available. |
| Pollyburger | $12.49 | Signature beef patty with lettuce, pickles, sweet onions, and Polly’s Special Dressing. Make it a Cheeseburger +$1.50 |
| Grilled Sourdough Burger | $13.99 | Burger on garlic-Parmesan grilled sourdough with onions, cheddar, lettuce, tomato, and pickles. |
| Pollymelt | $13.99 | Beef patty with grilled onions and Swiss or Cheddar on grilled sourdough bread. |
Homestyle Meals
| Item | Price | Description |
| Prime Rib Dinner | 8 oz – $19.99 13 oz – $25.99 | Oven-roasted prime rib with horseradish cream, au jus, smashed potatoes & veggies. Available Fri–Sun after 4pm. Add Shrimp +$5.99 |
| Grilled Norwegian Salmon | $19.99 | Atlantic salmon with veggies & herb rice. Choice of garlic lemon butter or Cajun chipotle. |
| Classic Meatloaf | $17.99 | House meatloaf with Jack cheese, veggies, smashed potatoes, and demi-glace. |
| Tenders Platter | $11.99 | Crispy chicken tenders served with fries and coleslaw. |
| Salisbury Steak | $15.99 | House-made steak, mushrooms, demi-glace, smashed potatoes & bacon green beans. |
| Chicken Pie Dinner | $15.99 | Savory chicken pie with veggies, gravy, smashed potatoes & cranberry sauce. |
| Chicken Fried Steak | $15.99 | Country gravy, smashed potatoes, and bacon green beans. |
| Beer-Battered Fish & Chips | $16.99 | Alaskan cod, fries, coleslaw, and tartar sauce. |
Pasta Dishes menu
| Item | Price | Description |
| NEW! Creamy Shrimp Pasta | $16.99 | Sautéed shrimp with penne in garlic Parmesan cream sauce. Served with garlic Parmesan toast. |
| Pasta Primavera | $13.99 | Cavatappi with mixed vegetables, garlic-butter sauce, Parmesan & basil. Served with garlic Parmesan toast. |
| Chicken Caliente Penne | $16.99 | Grilled chicken, veggies, penne in chipotle cream sauce, topped with cilantro. Served with garlic Parmesan toast. |
Polly’s Jr. Menu
🍽️ Kids’ Entrées
| Item | Price | Description |
| Silly Face Pancake | $5.99 | One pancake with fruit to create your own silly face. |
| Mini Pancakes & Egg | $5.99 | Mini pancakes with syrup & one egg. Includes choice of 1 side. Add toppings +$1 each. |
| French Toast Dippers & Egg | $5.99 | French toast with syrup & one egg. Includes choice of 1 side. |
| Egg & Toast | $5.99 | One egg with toast & Bumbleberry Jam. Includes choice of 1 side. |
| Pollyburger Jr. | $6.49 | Mini beef burger on a bun. Includes 1 Jr. side. Add cheese +$0.49. |
| Jr. Grilled Cheese | $6.49 | Grilled sourdough with cheese. Includes 1 Jr. side. |
| Mini Corn Dogs | $6.49 | Bite-sized corn dogs with ketchup. Includes 1 Jr. side. |
| Jr. Chicken Tenders | $6.49 | Crispy tenders with dipping sauce. Includes 1 Jr. side. |
| Jr. Pasta with Red Sauce | $6.49 | Cavatappi pasta in red sauce. Includes 1 Jr. side. |
| Jr. Mac & Cheese | $6.49 | Cheesy and hot! Includes 1 Jr. side. |
| Butter Noodles | $6.49 | Noodles with butter. Includes 1 Jr. side. |
🥗 Jr. Sides
Fries, Fruit Cup, Mac & Cheese, Green Beans, Smashed Potatoes & Gravy, Market Vegetables
🥤 Jr. Beverages
| Drink | Price |
| Jr. Drinks (Lemonade, Soda) | $1.79 |
| Jr. Premium Drinks | $2.49 |
| Milk, Chocolate Milk, Shirley Temple | |
| Jr. Juice (Apple, Orange) | $2.79 |
🍨 Jr. Desserts
| Dessert | Price |
| Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich | $2.99 |
| Kid’s Chocolate Chip Cookie | $1.49 |
| Ice Cream Sundae | $2.49 |
| Root Beer Float | $3.99 |
| Scoop of Vanilla Ice Cream | $1.49 |
🥤 Beverages
| Item | Price | Description |
| Pie Shakes | Pie + $1.99 | Upgrade any pie slice to a milkshake. No refills. |
| Polly Palmer | $4.49 | Fresh strawberry lemonade mixed with iced tea. No refills. |
| Strawberry Lemonade | $4.29 | Lemonade blended with sweet strawberries. No refills. |
| Iced Tea (Black or Mango) | $3.79 | Freshly brewed and chilled. |
| Lemonade | $3.79 | Classic house-made lemonade. |
| Apple or Cranberry Juice | $3.99 | Chilled juices. No refills. |
| Hot Tea | $3.79 | Steaming hot tea, served with lemon. |
| Soft Drinks | $3.49 | Coke, Diet Coke, 7Up, or Dr. Pepper. |
| Low-Fat or Chocolate Milk | $3.79 | Cold and refreshing. |
| Polly’s Gourmet Coffee | $3.99 | Regular, Decaf, or Dark Roast. |
| Cold Brew | $4.29 | 24-hour steeped cold brew, served black. No refills. |
| Vanilla or Caramel Cream Cold Brew | $5.29 | Cold brew with your choice of vanilla or caramel cream. No refills. |
Slices of Pie
| Item | Price | Description |
| Fresh Strawberry | $6.49 | Fresh CA strawberries in sweet glaze & flaky crust. |
| Key Lime Slice | $5.99 | Tart Key lime filling in graham crust with whipped cream. |
| Apple | $5.29 | Granny Smith apples with Polly’s special spices. |
| Apple (Splenda®) | $5.49 | Same classic apple pie, made with Splenda. |
| Apple Crisp | $5.99 | Spiced apples topped with a sweet, crumbly crisp. |
| Banberry® | $5.99 | Banana cream filling topped with strawberries & whipped cream. |
| Banberry® (Splenda®) | $6.49 | Sugar-free version of our Banberry® pie. |
| Banana Cream | $5.29 | Fresh bananas in vanilla custard with whipped cream & almonds. |
| Banana Cream (Splenda®) | $5.29 | Same as above, made with Splenda. |
| Cherry | $5.29 | Juicy tart cherries from Utah or Michigan. |
| Cherry (Splenda®) | $5.49 | Sugar-free cherry pie with the same great flavor. |
| Custard | $5.29 | Rich, creamy egg custard with a perfect spice blend. |
| Boysenberry | $6.49 | Tangy, luscious boysenberries in a flaky crust. |
| Chocolate Cream | $5.29 | Rich chocolate custard topped with whipped cream. |
| Coconut Cream | $5.29 | Hawaiian coconut in old-fashioned custard with whipped cream. |
| Lemon Meringue | $5.29 | Tart lemon filling under a fluffy toasted meringue. |
| Traditional Cheesecake | $7.49 | Classic cream cheese cheesecake on a graham crust. |
| Fruit Cheesecake | $7.99 | Classic cheesecake topped with sweet seasonal fruit. |
🥧 Whole Pies & Cheesecakes
| Item | Price | Description |
| Fresh Strawberry | $22.99 | California strawberries in glaze in a flaky crust. |
| Key Lime Pie | $21.99 | Tart Key lime filling in graham crust with whipped cream. |
| Apple | $17.99 | Granny Smith apples with house spice blend. |
| Apple (Splenda®) | $18.99 | Same as above, made with Splenda. |
| Apple Crisp | $19.99 | Spiced apples topped with sweet crumble. |
| Banberry® | $19.99 | Banana cream filling topped with strawberries & whipped cream. |
| Banberry® (Splenda®) | $20.99 | Sugar-free version of the Banberry® pie. |
| Boysenberry | $22.99 | Full of tangy boysenberry flavor. |
| Banana Cream | $17.99 | Bananas in vanilla custard, whipped cream & almonds. |
| Banana Cream (Splenda®) | $18.49 | Same banana cream pie, made with Splenda. |
| Cherry | $17.99 | Tart cherries from Utah or Michigan. |
| Cherry (Splenda®) | $18.99 | Sugar-free version of Polly’s cherry pie. |
| Coconut Cream | $17.99 | Hawaiian coconut in custard with whipped cream. |
| Chocolate Cream | $17.99 | Chocolate custard topped with whipped cream. |
| Chocolate Silk | $23.99 | Silky chocolate pie with whipped cream & shavings. |
| Custard | $16.99 | Classic creamy egg custard pie. |
| Lemon Meringue | $16.99 | Tart lemon filling with toasted meringue. |
🥧 Bake-at-Home Frozen Pies
| Item | Price | Description |
| Apricot (Bake-at-Home) | $16.99 | Sun-ripened apricots, frozen & ready to bake. |
| Blueberry (Bake-at-Home) | $16.99 | Wild & cultivated blueberries, frozen pie. |
| Rhubarb (Bake-at-Home) | $15.99 | Tangy-sweet Northwestern rhubarb pie, frozen. |
| Peach (Bake-at-Home) | $16.99 | Cinnamon-spiced peach pie, frozen & ready to bake. |
The Famous Pies: Sweet, Savory, and Always Fresh
At Polly’s Pies Menu, pie is the star. Each one is baked fresh daily and served with pride. Whether you love sweet or savory, there is a flavor for you:
- Banana Cream Pie
- Dutch Apple Pie with a cinnamon crumble
- Boysenberry Pie bursting with fruit
- Pumpkin Pie during the fall season
- Pecan Pie, a holiday staple
You can order by the slice or take home a whole pie. They also serve cookies, cinnamon rolls, and fresh muffins.
5 Must-Try Dishes at Polly’s Pies Restaurant Menu
If it is your first visit, here are five dishes you should not miss:
- Chicken Pot Pie – Rich, creamy, and baked in a golden crust. A must-have.
- Banana Cream Pie – Silky, sweet, and topped with whipped cream.
- Country Fried Steak – Hearty and comforting with a crispy coating.
- Fluffy Pancakes – Great for breakfast lovers. Light and buttery.
- Avocado Toast – A fresh and healthy option, served with a zesty twist.
Each dish showcases Polly’s passion for simple, satisfying food.
Flexible Dining: Dine In, Take Out, or Order Online
Polly’s makes it easy to enjoy your meal your way:
- Dine in at any cozy location
- Order online for pickup or delivery
- Use the Online Ordering System
Whether you need a quick bite or a family dinner, Polly’s is ready to serve.
Locations Across Southern California
Polly’s has restaurants throughout Southern California, including:
- Anaheim
- Whittier
- Fullerton
- Hemet
- Temecula
- Laguna Hills
Use the Store Locator to find the one closest to you.
Location on Map:
Polly’s Perks: The Rewards Program You Will Love
Join Polly’s Perks, their official rewards program. As a member, you get:
- A free slice of pie when you join
- Birthday perks
- Points for every dollar, redeemable for discounts
Sign up in-store or online here: Polly’s Perks
Catering for Every Occasion
Planning a meeting, birthday, or event? Polly’s Pies Restaurant provides reliable catering with options like:
- Breakfast platters
- Box lunches
- Whole pies and desserts
Perfect for casual get-togethers or special events. Submit your request on the Catering Page.
Polly’s Pies Restaurant & Bakery Reviews
Overall Rating: 3.9/5 (⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️) Based on 68 reviews. Tripadvisor.
Careers at Polly’s: Work That Feels Like Family
Looking for a job where you feel valued? Polly’s Pies Restaurant is hiring for roles like:
- Server
- Cook
- Manager
They offer growth, support, and a strong team culture. Apply online: Polly’s Careers
Plan Your Visit: Hours and Contact Info
Most locations are open daily from 7 AM to 9 PM. To contact a restaurant or place an order:
- Visit the Locations Page
- Place an order here: Order Polly’s
- For feedback or questions, use the Contact Form
Polly’s Pies Restaurant Business Hours
| Day | Hours |
| Sunday | 7 AM – 9 PM |
| Monday | 7 AM – 9 PM |
| Tuesday | 7 AM – 9 PM |
| Wednesday | 7 AM – 9 PM |
| Thursday | 7 AM – 9 PM |
| Friday | 7 AM – 9 PM |
| Saturday | 7 AM – 9 PM |
FAQs About Polly’s Pies Restaurant
Does Polly’s Pies Restaurant Menu serve breakfast all day?
Yes! Polly’s Pies serves breakfast all day at all locations.
How much are pies at Polly’s?
Whole pies usually cost between $16.99 and $23.99, depending on the flavor.
Pie slices range from $5.29 to $7.99.
What time does Polly’s Pies close?
Polly’s Pies typically closes at 9:00 PM every day.
(Check your local location to be sure.)
Who owns Polly’s Pies Restaurant?
Polly’s Pies has been family-owned and operated since it started in 1968.
Is Polly’s Pies Restaurant open today?
Yes, Polly’s Pies Restaurant is open every day from 7:00 AM to 9:00 PM.
What dish is Polly’s most famous for?
The Chicken Pot Pie and fresh-baked fruit pies are top sellers.
Are there vegan or gluten-free options?
Yes. Some pancakes can be made dairy-free, and other items accommodate specific diets.
Can I order holiday pies in advance?
Yes. Polly’s offers preorder options during Thanksgiving and Christmas.
Is there a rewards program?
Yes. Polly’s Perks offers points, birthday gifts, and exclusive deals.
Does Polly’s Pies Restaurant offer delivery?
Yes. You can order online for delivery or pickup through their official site.
Final Thoughts: Come Home to Polly’s
Polly’s Pies Restaurant brings together great food, warm service, and real value. From breakfast classics to fresh pies, everything is made with love. It is a place where memories are made and traditions are shared.
Visit Polly’s Pies Restaurant today. Take a seat, share a slice, and feel at home.
Please also read articles about the following Bakery restaurants:
- Weber’s Bakery: The Best Kept Secret for Artisanal Baked Goods
- Labriola Chicago: The Ultimate Italian Bakery You’ll Love
- Chiu Quon Bakery Chicago Menu: Authentic Dim Sum & Pastries Since 1986
- Levain Bakery Back Bay Boston: The Ultimate Dessert Paradise
- Blackbird Bakery Bainbridge Island Menu & Location | Taste the Magic
- Spinelli’s Bakery East Boston – Fresh Italian Pastries
- Fabrique Bakery 550 5th Ave Menu | Top 5 Best Items
- Jarosch Bakery Guide Menu & 5 Best Desserts in IL
- Collegeville Italian Bakery Pizzeria Napoletana | 5 Best Dishes
